Re:Systemd as tragedy
by zbentley on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @08:02PM
(#19031584)
> They broke userland.
That alludes to kernel development, which systemd is largely uninvolved with. A userland program chosen by various distributions failed to support conventions from a different userland program. That's all. Were the programs involved fundamental and highly important to many users' experience? Sure. Is busting out "you broke userland" like some magical shibboleth useful as a means of your conveying your unhappiness that your distribution maintainers chose to replace a widely-depended-upon program with a different program useful? I think not.
> they went against POSIX behaviour
Which? There's "tradition" and "specified behaviour". Both are important in different situations and in different degrees.
> You don't turn around and say that all the sysutils should incorporate your new idea.
Why not? They're no more privileged by the POSIX specification, or by the user/kernel -space divide than any other program.
That alludes to kernel development, which systemd is largely uninvolved with. A userland program chosen by various distributions failed to support conventions from a different userland program. That's all. Were the programs involved fundamental and highly important to many users' experience? Sure. Is busting out "you broke userland" like some magical shibboleth useful as a means of your conveying your unhappiness that your distribution maintainers chose to replace a widely-depended-upon program with a different program useful? I think not.
> they went against POSIX behaviour
Which? There's "tradition" and "specified behaviour". Both are important in different situations and in different degrees.
> You don't turn around and say that all the sysutils should incorporate your new idea.
Why not? They're no more privileged by the POSIX specification, or by the user/kernel -space divide than any other program.