News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by raincom on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @06:43PM (#19031084)
Western countries have lots of anti-corruption laws, but these laws won't help. Nor creating more laws would help either. What we have is: ethically corrupt but legally clean.
Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @07:03PM (#19031212)
Looking at the results, it seems quite obvious that most western countries have had significant success in curbing corruption. To just cynically dismiss these efforts would seem to both unhelpful (because why bother?) and just factually wrong.

I live in one of the top 20 countries, and have experience in countries in the lower half. The difference is like night and day. Imagine having to “tip” the EMT to take you to a hospital when you’ve been in a car accident. I had a local friend in Asian country who pretended to be unconscious in such a situation because they didn’t have any money on them.

Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by ra1n85 on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @08:14PM (#19031670)
Tipping an EMT is an example of low level corruption - the kind that comes with inadequate pay for government workers, lack of opportunities, etc. This is frightenly common in a lot of countries and culturally accepted as a kind of nuisance and fact of life.

I can’t say why this kind of corruption isn’t prevalent in the west(yet), but I don’t think it’s a fair comparison to the kind of corruption OP was describing.

Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by 75dvtwin on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @06:54PM (#19031152)
Exactly this.

Modern corruption vehicles include things like speeches, book publishing fees, movie/documentary fees, consulting fees, and real-estate deals where an expensive property is sold or rented for much less than market value.

Money laundering is done through complex derivatives, charitable foundations, and so on.

Basically modern day western corruption is based on the premise that 'work compensation' is 'discretionary' -- so any kind of 'work-like' engagement of a corrupted politician, or his/her immediate family members is easily turned into a bribe.

Even accidental (or minor) corruption of politicians, also adds to the rise of 'black mailing'. So there are politicians who have 'dirt on others', and that's their trading currency.

And so on, the swamp is continuing to snowball.

Some examples [1] http://time.com/3889577/hillary-clinton-paid-speeches-lobbyi...

[2] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic... I am sure others can find more.

Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by woodandsteel on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @07:56PM (#19031558)
So are you saying that all countries are corrupt, and approximately equally so? And is your conclusion that as a consequence trying to fight corruption is doomed to fail and so their is no point in trying?
Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by 75dvtwin on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @03:19PM (#19039003)
It is not the laws that are problem, it is the law-enforcement/justice system that's a problem.

Justice based on 'selective outrage 'cannot fix corruption.

Justice that's corrupt itself cannot fix corruption.

Western countries have, mostly, the former. Eastern Europe, and most so called developing nations, have both problems.

---

Somewhat separate topic...

But, to be honest, dislike the 'developing nations' moniker. I use it, but I wish there is something better...

As if inhabitants of those nations have 'less developed cognitive abilities, or 'less developed appetite for honesty'. That of course, is not true.

In reality the 'developing nations' are, mostly, intentionally suppressed nations, intentionally enslaved nations, intentionally brain-washed nations.

Where the suppressors are, often, their own leaders.

Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by throwaway5752 on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @07:43PM (#19031471)
You've never personally experienced actual corruption in your entire life, have you?
Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by decebalus1 on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @08:02PM (#19031586)
Growing up and living in Eastern Europe and then the US I agree with the post above you. I've experienced actual corruption (corrupt cops, doctors, small time civil servants, what have you) and I can see actual corruption in the US also. But it's 'legal' and way less prevalent at the lower levels.
Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by munk-a on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @06:45PM (#19031103)
I disagree, I believe corruption in western democracies can be addressed within their legal frameworks. A lot of the issues with money and politics have existed in some form or another for quite some time, but recently the excesses of corruption has become more extreme - still the American government is able to occasionally police itself, even if it's had trouble doing so recently.
Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by raincom on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @06:57PM (#19031173)
Even one removes the direct connection between money and politics, the current problems will take a different form: indirection. One kind of indirection we already see today: revolving doors

So, where is the root problem of all these? It is collusion of power(politics), media(intellectuals, think tanks), money(capitalists, wealthy bankers). These powerful classes constitute 0.5% of any society, but these classes are colluding in order to advance their own interests. Yes, we have elections. What happens then? It is another fight between one group of colluders and another group of colluders. In many cases, the powerful classes bet on the both sides.

How can one ban collusion? Look at office politics in any large organization. Think of banning collusions at work place.

Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by vkou on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @08:05PM (#19031605)
You don't ban collusion. I mean, you can, but it's not going to be particularly effective.

What you do, to solve this problem, is empower the lower classes.

We've just observed how two unions - air traffic controllers, and flight attendants - have accomplished, with the threat of a work stoppage, something that both the Republican, and the Democratic party failed to achieve - a re-opening of the government.

The 99.5% have all the power. What they need to do, is to use it in solidarity.

Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by throwaway5752 on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @07:45PM (#19031481)
You say that like it's profound. You need 1) laws 2) funding for enforcement 3) penalties for corruption. Absent any of the three, corruption will succeed.

The article directly references the broad systematic attack on 2 and 3 that's actively underway.

Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by siruncledrew on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @07:12PM (#19031278)
Any country could have anti-corruption laws, even Somalia has them. Doesn't mean they get enforced to same "ethical" degree as other countries. There's a lot of self-policing required to successfully bring corruption to justice and the offenders be held accountable. It's a lot harder to do than it sounds.
Re:Anti-corruption shortfalls fuelling ‘global democracy cri... by turtlecloud on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @07:09PM (#19031254)
Yes. The government is full of people who “follow the letter but not the spirit of the law”.