News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s Astonishing Altruism by StavrosK on Sunday November 14, 2010 @07:13AM (#1903089)
I disagree. Sure, it's susceptible to groupthink, but one comment by someone pointing this out is enough to turn the scales. I have never seen a single "don't downvote this guy, he's making a good point" not reverse the downvotes and lead to the person being upvoted (unless he wasn't making a good argument, but I've never seen that).
Re:Reddit’s Astonishing Altruism by kaens on Sunday November 14, 2010 @11:41AM (#1903517)
Do you read with no threshold, and read through entire threads? Read sorted by worst (or lowest or whatever it is)?

I used to. I stopped when the noise got too annoying to sift through, but I would see good comments hidden to most people by downvotes more often than never.

The "don't downvote this guy" reversal happens often, and it's really a very nice thing about the Reddit community, but a solid comment or argument is not guaranteed that treatment by any means, and sometimes that reversal doesn't actually work.

Re:Reddit’s Astonishing Altruism by StavrosK on Sunday November 14, 2010 @12:21PM (#1903605)
Sure, but the vast majority of the time I've seen (and done) it, it does work, and that's commendable. I firmly believe that redditors are a nudge away (if that) from great discussions, and a "he's making a good point" is enough to make redditors say "wait, I downvoted him because I disagree, not because his point is bad. Let me undo that".