News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Applications for tenure track CS position restricted to w... by qq66 on Sunday November 14, 2010 @04:41AM (#1902934)
Interesting thought experiment. This seems repugnant at face value. Would it be equally repugnant to have a scholarship restricted to Computer Science majors? How about a scholarship restricted to high academic achievers? What types of "discrimination" are OK? Where is the line drawn?
Re:Applications for tenure track CS position restricted to w... by rsheridan6 on Sunday November 14, 2010 @07:41AM (#1903131)
You can't discriminate against protected groups - minorities, women, and, increasingly, gays. Anybody else is fair game.
Re:Applications for tenure track CS position restricted to w... by sendos on Sunday November 14, 2010 @04:58AM (#1902956)
It's drawn at things you can change about you. You can become a Computer Science major, and you can study hard and become a high academic achiever. But you can't become a woman if you're not.

EDIT: I assume it's clear that the above means "It's drawn at things you can change about you without resorting to surgery" and "you can't become a woman if you're not, without surgery"

Re:Applications for tenure track CS position restricted to w... by ojbyrne on Sunday November 14, 2010 @06:04AM (#1903032)
I think, in law, that's not actually how it works. The operative phrase is "bona fide job requirements." for example if you're a fireman, it's acceptable to require that you be physically fit to some level. If you're a CS professor, you would have a harder time justifying such a requirement. That's an attribute that you can change.

IANAL, etc.

Re:Applications for tenure track CS position restricted to w... by krakensden on Sunday November 14, 2010 @05:17AM (#1902972)
you can for legal purposes, and you can get pretty close physically as well.
Re:Applications for tenure track CS position restricted to w... by sendos on Sunday November 14, 2010 @05:35AM (#1903001)
Yes, but I hardly think that it's OK to ask people to undergo a sex-change operation to get a job (I do think it's perfectly OK to ask people to become good in a specific field to get a job in that field)

And the general point stands, because many other things you can't change about yourself (like your race) shouldn't be the basis of discriminating for job positions.

Re:Applications for tenure track CS position restricted to w... by dtby on Sunday November 14, 2010 @06:16AM (#1903040)
It's drawn at things you can change about you.

What makes this reasonable?