News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reddit’s Astonishing Altruism by jrockway on Sunday November 14, 2010 @04:18AM (#1902910)
creepy church youth groups or after school specials

Yes, yes! Exactly!

I used to read programming reddit, and made a lot of comments there. Then I started to notice a pattern -- people were so happy that they wrote a blog post that it was suddenly forbidden to comment on it. One post I remember reading was something like, "hey guys, I made a PHP app! it's open source so please comment". The app was doing something like submitting a form field like "?shell_command=someapp%20--args". I said it was maybe not good practice to allow the user to supply an arbitrary UNIX command. The reply was, "well, my app sets that, and nobod is going to change it". I told him anyone could change the URL and run whatever they want. This got downmodded and I was told I was being an "idiot jerk".

Then I didn't read reddit anymore. Obviously I was raining on some sort of special parade that I was not even invited to.

Anyway, there's something off about the Reddit community. I think your post sums it up quite well.

Re:Reddit’s Astonishing Altruism by pbiggar on Sunday November 14, 2010 @07:34AM (#1903119)
Sadly, the quality of programming.reddit went way way down, but there are lots of reddit communities that didn't. For example, people founded the coding reddit because programming became so bad.