a few (and i mean very few) examples. Aircraft carrier bought from russia to copy, J-20 stole (allegedly) F-22 designs from the US and modified, segway - ninebot, J-11B fighter they copied from the su-27. The list goes on and on. Here is a link with greate examples and Pictures (https://news.usni.org/2015/10/27/chinas-military-built-with-...).
Again this is not knocking the engineers in China, their reverse engineering is second to none. Reminds me of the "Pakled" on Star Trek TNG, they just aquire all technology from other races and make it work.
Side note, trade secrets != patents. The whole idea between the two is fundamentally different.
In retrospect, it's clear how much that mentality undervalues what was being taught in the course. Yeah, the initial approach might be obvious, but so are plenty more initial approaches. What made it through to the course and was put down in the textbook are the few initial approaches that actually worked.
/Textbooks should have a long list of attempted approaches that seemed great and weren't, but no one publishes failures.
I look at the system as an admission that it's impossible to know, post-hoc, whether something was copied or independently developed.
We wouldn't have a problem with no patents, if we could only determine that.
Agree that it seems like there should be more of an obviousness floor (e.g. "Can a reasonably trained engineer build this in less than a week?").
It is a little ridiculous as you say, but the fact that a company was obviously involved in attempts at industrial espionage makes it kind of serious.
As a side thought, this is the kind of thing that is wrong with our patent system:
Implementation is confused with invention. The USPTO grants patents for things that any reasonable engineering team would implement given a problem to solve.
Engineering is about problem solving. Not all solutions are inventions. In fact, I would argue that there are very few true inventions these days and that the general rate of true inventions should naturally decline over time.
In other words, the threshold for what should constitute a true patentable invention, given accumulated knowledge, should increase with time.