"Anything too intellectual will likely get a TL;DR type reaction."
I mostly agree with your post except for this. I actually find that Redditor's are extremely good about offering a counterpoint to a sensational title. Oftentimes, someone in the field related to the article will post something intellectual debunking the story (especially in the case of something to do with science or medicine) which will offer far more additional material than the source itself.
I think it really depends on the subreddit. Once you start getting into speciality subreddits, the level of the discourse increases.
Re:Reddit’s Astonishing Altruism
by crocowhile on Sunday November 14, 2010 @06:17AM
(#1903043)
I think you are all being very unfair. I find the same proportions of insightful comments on reddit and HN but I find HN has a form of snobism that I profoundly dislike. Not in all users, but it's obviously there and sucks.
If you avoid the stupidest subreddits (/pics, /funny, etc) it's actually amazing what high level of discussion you can meet. (while having a good laugh too, btw).
To put in the cliché Freudian speak -- Reddit is the Id and HN is Superego.
Reddit is the place to call people stupid, post silly pictures of cats, but also a place to get together and donate for a cause, talk someone out of a suicide, or just spread around stupid memes for fun. A well placed witty one-liners will get you hundreds of upvotes. Anything too intellectual will likely get a TL;DR type reaction.
HN is the site that discusses issues in depth, rational, evidence backed arguments are expected, civility and maturity is expected as well. A stupid one liner will most likely be frowned upon.
But I think we need both. I am a member of both sites and both provide for a what I consider a healthy outlet for my online presence.