https://www.cnbc.com/2015/08/27/the-inspiring-story-of-the-w...
It's not that 100% stocks doesn't give you long term return, on a 30 year spread, it gives better returns (although more volatile) than more balanced portfolios. 10% bonds, while you're young, is mostly just to keep you from freaking out and selling at a low point. If you have an iron will, there's nothing mathematically wrong with that level of risk.
My guess is there's more to this story than poor allocation.
Some really good Bogleheads discussion here:
https://www.bogleheads.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=196011
That being said, indexing is common now but Active was more common in the 80s, so who knows how much money was lost on ineffective managers.
Also keep in mind this guy is in Canada and the GFC was not nearly as severe as in the USA.
The household savings rate in Canada is quite awful [0], and is currently at the lowest rate in their recorded history.
The US, where household savings are known to be bad, and it was recently seen how awful it was with government workers unable to pay for food, is at 6%. Canda is 0.8%.
I think even buying at the peaks you'd be up.
Now, the information wasn't as easily available about how to properly invest back then, and I don't necessarily blame the guy for it. Not necessarily, but there is still probably a better than even chance that he has mismanaged his money, as so many do. Doesn't mean he should have to suffer, though.
1. My employer matches 50% of my contribution up to the cap. Not entirely uncommon at big tech cos, but maybe less common in smaller enterprises.
2. I also did $50k of in-plan conversions over the last two years.
After you take all those sources out (and the resulting investment proceeds from the funds from those sources), my total is only $400k. I do still think it is correct that someone investing ($2019)5k/y since the 80s would have generated a sizable nest egg by now, but my own experience does not make that case as strongly as I had thought.
Actually, when I run it through a calculator assuming 5% total returns, it looks like that hypothetical person only saves about $700k. Which is enough to live a reasonably good life in retirement, but not marvelous wealth by any stretch.
Let's say he started a 401K in his 20s and slid the meter all the way to right (riskier investments). He would have encountered:
- 1980 recession, the one that got Reagan elected.
- 1990 recession, the one that got Clinton elected.
- 2001 recession, this one mainly affected tech workers.
- 2008 recession, this is the major one.
The GFC in 2008 have left a lot of older workers in the lurch. Many are now coming up on retirement and they were heavily invested in the stocks and not so much bonds. In my case my parents have lost $80k in their 401K. They have only just recovered.
And that example is just 401k, IRA. We won't even get into other matters such as health, divorce, property, lawsuits, failed businesses.