Re:CDE: Easily run a program on any linux without thinking a...
by pgbovine on Saturday November 13, 2010 @05:39PM
(#1901892)
thanks for reposting, sfk. i don't know why the original comment would've been killed ... chbarts brought up a great critique about my presentation of cde.
Re:CDE: Easily run a program on any linux without thinking a...
by blasdel on Saturday November 13, 2010 @07:51PM
(#1902131)
It looks like they got capriciously hellbanned for comments in this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1320949 — everything after that was auto-killed, several dozen productive comments over the course of six months.
Items can be fully deleted or [dead]-ed, and users can be silently hellbanned so that all of their contributions are [dead] on arrival for everyone but themselves. AFAIK there are no other metamoderation mechanisms.
chbarts wrote:
" I think the potted example on the web page is somewhat poor, as it seems to be a problem existing package management systems already solve.
The more interesting aspect is the sandboxing, and how this is great for one-off software runs where it isn't worth it to install the needed packages on your base system because they're logically just a unit with the software you're testing. You mention this, but I think you'd do well to make it more obvious.
This is also, and this is something you mention, a way of preserving historic software and data. Bundle a full CDE package with an emulator and you can keep running that program for even longer; in fact, it seems a CDE package could gradually grow layers as time demands, from moving a (user-mode) kernel in, to adding device emulation, to going the final step and making the package more-or-less a ship in a bottle running in full hardware emulation.
This could also grow into a way to run untrusted (or minimally-trusted) software in an iron box, not just a sandbox. But that is harder and probably not your preferred direction."