Or as John Carmack has said, low-level programming is good for the programmer's soul, it's hard to imagine that programmers do have souls if they has never been exposed to low-level programming. Unfortunately, in the modern computing world, the chances are becoming fewer and fewer, most systems are far beyond a complete understanding for most people. I think I'll never completely understand the x86_64 instruction set (w/ SSE, SSE2, FMA, AVX), or the signal path of the PCI-E interface on my motherbard.
Recently, I think some popular microcontroller projects may be the solution for a bare-metal programming experience.
But we can also looking it from another perspective - the proliferation of mobile devices changed everything, nowadays, even using a general purpose computer is not an experience that many members of the new generation may have (there was a Hacker News article about it). Some don't understand a hierarchical filesystem of files and directories anymore, and others have problem typing on a physical keyboard. In this sense, to blink an LED on Raspberry Pi is already a big step forward, and it was exactly the motivation behind Raspberry Pi.
I like to think that it is possible we'll one day develop a CPU architecture that is both simple enough to reason about and also highly performant.
RISC-V is getting there, with open-hardware cores such as Rocket (in-order) and BOOM (out-of-order). Too bad that many and perhaps most of the peripheral components even on a general-purpose SiFive SoC are still closed hardware blocks. But people are working on opening these up as well.
I say the point is that you should try to do trivial things with complex control systems and vice versa. You’ll do it better and more efficiently the second time. And the third. And if you decide to scale it, you will quickly learn the cheapest way to blink 10,000 LEDs.
Needless to say the whole thing was replaced by single ~$20 chinese FX1N clone (which also neatly solved how to drive 24V industrial loads from RPi/Arduino/ESP...).
I disagree a bit with you (I do agree that if all the RPi ends up doing is flashing a LED, then that is a waste) You have to start somewhere and if it is flashing a LED with a Pi then cool. The path to ESP32 or ESP8266 is not far away and there is a lot, lot more to discover and play with and learn and frankly have fun with and maybe do something useful or change the world (or a tiny bit of it) with.
I had some of the best opportunities available to me in IT and electronics and electrics, schools, teachers etc etc etc. but I didn't have today's opportunities. If I was growing up today I think I would probably have started with a Pi and blinked some LEDs.
[0] https://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/texas-instruments/...
I checked that site and "medium quantities" is 5000 of them :) (for a total price of $493). Somewhere on the page it says minimum amount is 2500, but I tried and wasn't able to successfully add that to my cart (only 5000).
So I guess that's nice, but how are you going to put even 2500 of these chips to use? That's a LOT of soldering to do. Unless you have some kind of machine to do that for you? But even then what are you going to use 2500 of them for, if not for reselling?
Good point.
> something like an ESP32 runs circles around the PCW1512, which we had on the school computer club
I think as long as people are having fun with them, the hardware already served a good purpose. Even if the LED blinking is implemented by running Linux.
But in my opinion, people who are interested in these popular embedded boards should also learn about the basis of electronics, or just be aware of its existence, and understand the things one could do without buying a premade "board", and that it's possible to blink an LED with a few transistors. Well, I think most will find out by themselves, it's just a matter of time and guidance.