Re:JMAP: Like IMAP but Not Really
by lucideer on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:25AM
(#18996904)
Yes. And the vision for Google Wave was great. The execution was just abominably bad (primarily on the frontend/UI side), and Google's failures in execution carried over reputationally to the—now dead—Apache incubator.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Not just the UI side. The underlying protocol was also pointlessly over-engineered. SMTP is still around because it is simple. You can get a basic SMTP client running in an hour or two. You can get a basic server running in a similar amount of time, at least in a higher level language. That matters, not because anyone will have anything usable in that time, but because it lets you start to experiment very, very easily.
Wave suffered from a UI that was a mess layered on top of a protocol that made it really hard for people to get started on experimenting with alternative frontends, and without a user-base giving people a reason to persist figuring out how to interoperate with it. Had the protocol been simpler, the UI mess might not have mattered so much - people might have come up with their own ideas.
The S in SMTP literally stands for Simple. And it was developed in 1982. So it was considered simple in 1982.
That gives you some idea how simple it is.
It is simple today, except for the authentication.
Of course, if the authentication doesn't work, nothing works!