Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by xyxxxx on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:03AM
(#18996827)
Yeah, totally ignorant. If there is a database with DNA from everyone, you can trivially frame anybody.
It is usually easy to obtain DNA from a specific person and put it at the crime scene.
I'm sure Mr Harran's DNA won't be found in any database.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by gtsteve on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:23AM
(#18996898)
My understanding that these databases effectively contain a checksum which has a very low chance of collision. I don't know if you could actually make DNA material from that checksum.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by gmarkoff on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:31AM
(#18996933)
The comment you replied to did not mention making DNA material. DNA can be obtained directly from the target.
CCC members has obtained fingerprints from politicians, for example. DNA is no harder.
Or don't target a specific person, but place random hair found in a public toilet.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by omeid2 on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:51AM
(#18997003)
Not only is obtaining DNA contaminated samples not harder than fingerprints, it is orders of magnitude easier.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by jarfil on Friday January 25, 2019 @12:40AM
(#18995847)
I can believe they don't target "particular groups", just "every group".
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by AmericanChopper on Friday January 25, 2019 @12:26AM
(#18995802)
Anybody who parrots ‘nothing to hide’ or anything similar needs to read The Trial. If we’re heading towards a dystopia, I don’t think it will be Orwell’s, I think it will be Kafka’s.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by ClassyJacket on Friday January 25, 2019 @12:51AM
(#18995872)
Anyone who parrots 'nothing to hide' should have a public webcam in their shower.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by LoSboccacc on Friday January 25, 2019 @02:09AM
(#18996126)
"My problem with quips like these -- as right as they are -- is that they accept the premise that privacy is about hiding a wrong."
https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2006/05/the_eternal...
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by tremon on Friday January 25, 2019 @07:26AM
(#18997359)
suggesting a webcam in the shower is not about "hiding a wrong".
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by vinceguidry on Friday January 25, 2019 @09:09AM
(#18997941)
Parent was agreeing with the grandparent.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by AmericanChopper on Friday January 25, 2019 @12:59AM
(#18995895)
While that argument is valid, it doesn’t touch on the true nefariousness of ‘nothing to hide’. Which is how a secretive bureaucracy can interpret isolated facts any way they please, and place the burden of proof onto the accused. A real life example would be the no fly list. How do you get on it? How do you get off it? The best example in fiction would be Kafka’s The Trial, imo.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday January 25, 2019 @03:52AM
(#18996523)
Weird, because this genuinely wouldn't bother me, while being on a DNA database would.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by JoeSmithson on Friday January 25, 2019 @03:44AM
(#18996493)
I don't understand your point. It's possible to not want your nude photos public while also being comfortable submitting your DNA to a government database.
I personally probably wouldn't submit my DNA without a particular reason, but I don't see what's the contradiction here?
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by Haga on Friday January 25, 2019 @04:08AM
(#18996613)
Ever been in a liason with a policemen wife and had your DNA turn up in a murder case?
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by Spare_account on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:06AM
(#18996841)
You're missing the point. Everyone in this thread agrees that submitting DNA voluntarily is a bad thing. There is no need to pursue that part.
The confusion felt by some in this sub-thread is the analogy between 'having nothing to hide' and 'having a pub webcam in your shower'.
I don't see the connection either.
Re:Coming Soon to a Police Station Near You: The DNA ‘Magic ...
by L4H6MM6V12JQ on Friday January 25, 2019 @12:37AM
(#18995834)
I'm not sure. I have always interpreted the "Nothing to hide" line as being past tense. Mr. Harran's statement is arguably future tense.
This is the exact same argument made against the right to privacy.