Re:AlphaStar: Mastering the Real-Time Strategy Game StarCraf...
by celeritascelery on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:07PM
(#18993979)
I get what your saying. But screen movement is rate limited (meaning you can't loop through all possible screen positions in 1ms) so you have to actively choose where you want to focus, just like a human player. Think of it more like calls to a web server then "foreach screens".
Re:AlphaStar: Mastering the Real-Time Strategy Game StarCraf...
by shawnz on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:13PM
(#18994015)
Can't you click on the minimap to move the camera instantly anywhere on the map?
EDIT: I guess you would still have to wait for the next frame to get rendered, which could add up. True, that does change things a bit, but of course a computer could still do that way faster than a human.
Let me put it the opposite way: If you gave the human player a real time list of every visible unit on the map and all of their information, such that they didn't have to move the screen around manually and could see everything at a glance just like AlphaStar can, would that take the advantage away from AlphaStar? No, it wouldn't because AlphaStar could still go through all that data much faster than any human ever could -- no matter how it's formatted or what you have to do to access it. To AlphaStar, checking all the visible screens is just as much work as scrolling through a list of units.