Less than 50 years ago, they carried their rifles to school on the bus every day, and kept them in their lockers. They also took gun safety courses in school. I don't find it at all surprising that kids are less responsible with guns now: when I work with kids, I find they live up (or down) to the level of your expectations.
> The author would probably kill his cattle in a humane way, but can we count on everyone to do so?
From everything I've seen, many/most farms still don't, so the USDA is more of a nuisance for those that want to do it right, than a way to force the bad ones to improve. The government is made up of people, too: you can't just sprinkle farms with the magic pixie dust of "government regulation" and have everything magically work out.
I agree with you if you are talking about adults. But what about their children? Should a child die just because their parents decided that a prayer would cure them?
Most regulations aren't there to protect what people do to themselves, but to limit what they can do to others.
A responsible child can probably carry a gun to school, but do you trust all children?
The author would probably kill his cattle in a humane way, but can we count on everyone to do so?