Re:Oracle and Apple Announce OpenJDK Project for Mac OS X
by rbanffy on Friday November 12, 2010 @11:12AM
(#1898084)
> If I release an open source product, but then say you can only make modifications and sell it if you pass my tests (which I don't make freely available), it's not really open right?
I believe your restriction on making derived works conflicts with just about every free and open-source license out there. What Sun did and Oracle does prohibit you from doing is calling something that doesn't pass the non-freely-available TCK by the name Java or implying it's Java-compatible.
As for Dalvik, it's not derived from a project Oracle contributed the said patents. In this way, Dalvik is not protected agains Oracle's lawyers.
Re:Oracle and Apple Announce OpenJDK Project for Mac OS X
by va_coder on Friday November 12, 2010 @11:27AM
(#1898144)
I think reversing a linked-list using recursion is a walk in the park compared to trying to understand patent/trademark law for software.
Re:Oracle and Apple Announce OpenJDK Project for Mac OS X
by scott_s on Friday November 12, 2010 @10:59AM
(#1898034)
I believe the reason is that it was not derived from anything, such as OpenJDK, that had existing licensing protection.
Re:Oracle and Apple Announce OpenJDK Project for Mac OS X
by stonemetal on Friday November 12, 2010 @12:33PM
(#1898394)
You would not get a trademark lawsuit. Patents have different rules.
There's more to it than that. If I call it Dalvik, like Google did, why would I get a lawsuit?
Edit: I have to say I don't think I even understand what open source means anymore. If I release an open source product, but then say you can only make modifications and sell it if you pass my tests (which I don't make freely available), it's not really open right?