News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by pbalau on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @09:39AM (#18978436)
The biggest difference between a DSLR and a mirrorless is the wayfinder: on mirrorless you get digital vs analog on dslr (via the mirror system). In terms of controls, both have more or less the same, with some naming differences.

I would go for second hand set, either canon or nikon, whatever model!, with the stock zoom lens (18-55) and get a fixie (not zoom lens, 50mm works great for lots of conditions and most of them are fast). This should cover you for a while, maybe even years. When you literally run the thing down and think you can't progress anymore, you will most likely have a clear idea what you want from a camera.

Don't get bogged down by all the awesome new things cameras can do, to learn you need aperture priority and shutter priority. You will find that all decent cameras have that. Probably, pretty quickly you will need manual iso and white balance settings, but again, most cameras have that too.

So, go on, buy the cheapest set you can find, that' still a dslr with changeable lenses, get the two lenses I recommended and start shooting. After you figure out what you like to shoot, because you will never be able to shoot everything at the same level, focus on that.

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by bigredhdl on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @10:48AM (#18979178)
I agree with a lot of this. I took a photography class in college and learned more on a borrowed old 35mm taking and developing black and whites than anything I have used since. People (myself included) tend to focus way too much on the gear, but when you are starting out go way cheap so you can get a feel for what you like to shoot and where your gear might be limiting you. Then after you go through that process make a more informed decision about what system you want to invest in. Definitely get you a zoom and a prime lens though as stated above.

I highly recommend taking a class in person. It really is the best bang for your buck. After that I think the best way to learn is just getting out there and taking shots. Get away from the gear reviews and spend that time practicing . Find out what you like and what you don't. Really its about you enjoying your own shots not trying to meet someone else's arbitrary standard of what makes a shot good enough.

Personally, I now shoot mirrorless. My first DSLR was an Olympus E-520 which served me very well. I reached a point where I was going to have to invest in more lenses, but Olympus had switched to micro 4/3 mirrorless and I was hesitant to invest in a system without a clear upgrade path. I then upgraded to a Pentax k-70 which was a decent camera, but I had so many focus issues with it I quickly sold it and now I've made the plunge into the Sony mirrorless system and plan on staying there and investing in it. Its a joy to shoot.

Finally, remember most of the greatest photographers in history had less capable cameras than the one you will have in your hand.

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by jsjohnst on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @11:38AM (#18979770)
> on mirrorless you get digital vs analog on dslr

There’s plenty of dSLRs with digital viewfinders at all price points in virtually all brands.

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by pbalau on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:01PM (#18980016)
why they need the mirrors then? (genuinely asking)
Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by jsjohnst on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:52PM (#18981334)
The mirror is for the small optical viewfinder window at the top. When you hit the button for live preview, the mirror is “locked up” and the main sensor powers a “live view” on the LCD screen which gives you a preview including aperture/iso/exposure/etc settings all applied just like on many mirrorless cameras.

The reason the small viewfinder exists is because it draws power to keep the sensor on and the mirror locked up. Keeping the sensor on for long periods of time can cause the sensor to heat up which will degrade picture quality (albeit not by a lot with current high end sensors, so the main reason is power draw). Historically the focusing and E-TTL sensors were also only on the same side of the mirror as the optical viewfinder, so you’d lose auto-focus and flash metering when the mirror was locked up, but that is generally not the case anymore.

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by pbalau on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:37PM (#18981875)
> The mirror is for the small optical viewfinder

That's what I meant. It didn't occur to me that the bigger display is a viewfinder too...

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by jsjohnst on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:27AM (#18987755)
Yes, it is, unless you want to be uber pedantic.
Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by Someone1234 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @12:23PM (#18980266)
Yeah. I think the person above is confusing a digital overlay with a digital viewfinder. Apples and oranges.

As useful as digital overlays are (and they are, particularly the graphs) they cannot do what an LCD viewfinder can do which is to say completely "demo" what the final picture will look like (i.e. show the results of shutter speed and ISO settings).

Mirrored lens cameras still have their usages. I'd definitely take one for high speed sports shooting in particular (even the best LCDs introduce some latency).

But for day to day, particularly learning photography, digital viewfinders are a huge improvement that make mirrorless worth it all by themselves. I'd never go back to a DSLR, the loss of information in the viewfinder is a massive deficit (not to mention the weight/size/unreliability).

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by jsjohnst on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @01:50PM (#18981302)
> they cannot do what an LCD viewfinder can do which is to say completely "demo" what the final picture will look like (i.e. show the results of shutter speed and ISO settings).

I’m definitely not talking about an overlay. I’m talking live full demo view on the LCD screen. The mirror is “locked up” when the LCD screen is on and you get a preview of what the end result photo would be just like you describe isn’t possible.

From Wikipedia[0], here’s a list of the first model supporting live view of each respective series:

Canon: 20Da, 40D, 450D, 1000D, 1D Mark III, 5D Mark II, 6D Mark II, 7D

Fujifilm: FinePix S3 Pro, FinePix IS Pro

Leica: Digilux 3

Nikon: D90, D300, D700, D3

Olympus: E-10, E-330, E-30, E-3

Panasonic: DMC-L1

Pentax: K20D, K-7, K-x

Samsung: GX-20

Sony: A300, A350, A500, A55, and A77

As most of those cameras were released ~10 years ago and as the Wikipedia article indicates “there is no product line in which live preview has been abandoned after being introduced”, there are now probably almost a hundred models of dSLRs with live preview functionality, if not more. In fact, that article goes on to state:

> and almost all new DSLRs have had the feature since mid-2008

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Live_preview

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by Someone1234 on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:21PM (#18981681)
Which is completely off-topic. The discussion is Viewfinders. Even your own reply above referenced Viewfinders specifically:

> There’s plenty of dSLRs with digital viewfinders

A digital Viewfinder actually has an LCD (or other type of digital display) within the Viewfinder assembly itself. It has nothing to do with the rear/main display at all.

Your other reply makes me think you don't know what the Viewfinder is. So here's some references:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viewfinder

https://photo.stackexchange.com/questions/50028/whats-the-pr...

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by jsjohnst on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:29AM (#18987767)
Many mirrorless cameras only have an LCD screen, so are we saying they don’t have a viewfinder? The context wasn’t your pedantic view of what a viewfinder is, the context was comparing mirrorless cameras to dSLR cameras. I have clearly laid out a case why OPs critique of dSLRs only having optical viewfinders (which they called “analog”) is misguided with extensive examples and a solid basis for my claim. The fact you are so focused on your definition of a single word shows you are trying to “win” the debate rather than be factual and genuine, so I’ll say have a “great day!” and continue on with my life.
Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by Someone1234 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @10:47AM (#18989656)
> Many mirrorless cameras only have an LCD screen, so are we saying they don’t have a viewfinder?

Yes. That's what everyone says, manufacturers, retailers, and customers. Take for example this comparison chart on Olympus' website. Note some cameras, with a rear display have no Viewfinder listed where there is none:

https://www.getolympus.com/us/en/pen#products-table-1

They call the rear screen the "monitor." Which seems fine, but I've also read it called the rear display, main display, preview screen, and so on.

> The context wasn’t your pedantic view of what a viewfinder is

If I call an apple an "apple," that isn't a pedantic view, that's the name of the object. If I call a Viewfinder a "Viewfinder" that is no less a pedantic view, and instead the name of thing we're discussing.

In general you obviously misunderstood what the word viewfinder meant, and went off on a rant that didn't make a whole lot of sense as a result. I'd suggest you go try a mirrorless camera with a digital viewfinder and report back when you have the prerequisite knowledge for this topic.

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by jsjohnst on Thursday January 24, 2019 @04:19PM (#18993067)
> I'd suggest you go try a mirrorless camera with a digital viewfinder and report back when you have the prerequisite knowledge for this topic.

I own two of them. I also own a bunch of dSLRs too. I also am a professional photographer with decades of experience with camera gear.

I’d suggest you not assume things about others without having sufficient context, but at least you’ve now proven my assumption about you was warranted, despite not having enough perspective to prove it before.

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by Someone1234 on Thursday January 24, 2019 @06:27PM (#18994096)
It is a reasonable assumption given that you didn't know what a Viewfinder was, and keep insisting the screen on the back is one even now.

When your mistake was pointed out by multiple posters, you then doubled down, called the industry standard terminology that is likely older than either of us "pedantic."

It is fine to not know things, or to have holes in your knowledge. It isn't fine to keep on doubling down rather than admit obvious mistakes.

All you had to do was read the Wikipedia article on Viewfinders in the "decades" you've been "professionally" taking photos.

Re:Ask HN: DSLR vs. MirrorLess cameras. Best resources for l... by pbalau on Wednesday January 23, 2019 @02:39PM (#18981904)
To be pedantic, the topic started about "wayfinders". But that shows I'm an idiot, so let's not talk about that