Re:Is genius simply the product of hard work?
by pbhjpbhj on Friday November 12, 2010 @07:22AM
(#1897408)
>It's a nice quote, but it physically must be the case that Feynman was not doing magic, but was doing thinking with human thought processes, within the confines of a human brain and all that entails.
Many would argue that inspiration has an external origin (indeed the word itself indicates this). Be that origin God, a spirit [of some other form] or the universe itself. In which case Feynman is effectively doing magic and as it is based on his relationship to the source of that magic it is not reproducable.
In this sense the magic is something unmeasurable and inaccessible except by being the particular person, I think it is beyond scientific discoverability but not (in a Popperian sense) unfalsifiable. For example a synthetic brain that demonstrated emergent inspiration without an external source - something like an AI network that was generally programmed but wrote entire symphonies in it's "head" or formed unprovable postulates which later took on status as well verified theories.
In short you're supposing a physical explanation. I'm not supposing a non-physical one, but certainly one that lies outside the bounds of standard models (!).
Many would argue that inspiration has an external origin (indeed the word itself indicates this). Be that origin God, a spirit [of some other form] or the universe itself. In which case Feynman is effectively doing magic and as it is based on his relationship to the source of that magic it is not reproducable.
In this sense the magic is something unmeasurable and inaccessible except by being the particular person, I think it is beyond scientific discoverability but not (in a Popperian sense) unfalsifiable. For example a synthetic brain that demonstrated emergent inspiration without an external source - something like an AI network that was generally programmed but wrote entire symphonies in it's "head" or formed unprovable postulates which later took on status as well verified theories.
In short you're supposing a physical explanation. I'm not supposing a non-physical one, but certainly one that lies outside the bounds of standard models (!).