News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by rayiner on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:41PM (#18970982)
I don't see the hypocrisy. Does the Singapore-EU trade agreement give EU citizens the right to vote on laws that will be binding upon Singaporeans? Or give EU citizens the right to reside and work in Singapore? If not, there is no hypocrisy in supporting Brexit while relocating to Singapore.

It is disingenuous to portray the EU as merely a trade organization. It may have started out that way, but today it is a supra-national government, capable of binding the citizens of member states to laws those citizens oppose (just as, e.g., the United States federal government can bind citizens of Alabama to laws those citizens oppose). See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_(European_Union)

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by graeme on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:47PM (#18971048)
That seems the wrong question. The better question is: why did he stay in britain while it was in the EU, and why is he leaving now that the UK is leaving the EU? Especially as he advocated that leaving would improve trade and industry.

The answer might be as simple as: "Signapore was the right place and we were planning this move before Brexit was on the horizon"

But it certainly gives the appearance that Brexit is bad for business and he doesn't want to operate with the consequences of the policy he advocated.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by switch007 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:49PM (#18971068)
Not to be a pedant, and it it doesn't invalidate your comment, and probably for the benefit of others, but the UK is still in the EU.
Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by graeme on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:57PM (#18971169)
Thanks, fixed it. Had meant to write leaving and not in.
Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by zeroname on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:50PM (#18971082)
In the short run, Brexit will be bad for business, especially if it happens as uncoordinated as it looks now. In the long run, nobody knows, but at least there's potential to negotiate favorable deals without dealing with the EU.
Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by jayalpha on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:54PM (#18971134)
Out of curiosity, what kind of "undiscovered territory" were you thinking about?

As posted by me before:

a) USA. Very little taxes in trade with the EU already. Little to gain with FTA.

b) Canada? Okay, but the UK has this Free trade agreement (FTA) already via the EU.

c) Mersocur? FTA to be signed with the EU soon.

d) Japan und Korea? Have FTAs with EU

e) India? Very demanding. Also want easier immigration to the UK in a FTA. Prediction: Will fail.

f) Australia? Ok, easy to get. Point for the UK

g) China? Possible. But only goods, since China loves to export goods. Financial services? Forget about it. Also, trust me, the Chinese have not forgotten the Opium war. Also the recent Ship of the Royal Navy in disputed waters did not help.

h) Africa. Many (economically) small countries. Not all countries have ties to the UK.

i) Russia/CIS. This the UK could get but this they don't want.

So?

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by fmajid on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @03:09PM (#18971919)
e) is particularly egregious, as it is given as an example of how the EU is hobbling the UK. In fact the EU-India FTA negotiations failed because of British intransigence on the Indian demand for streamlined (non-immigrant) visas, vetoed by the then UK Home Secretary,... Theresa May.
Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by checkdigit15 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @03:30PM (#18972122)
> "how the EU is hobbling the UK"

Sorry if I'm misreading, but do you mean "how the EU is being hobbled by the UK"? In the sentence above it sounds like the EU wanted the agreement but the UK (and May's veto) prevented the EU from doing it.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by graeme on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @06:35PM (#18973954)
They mean people in the uk say that the eu hobbled the uk's ability to trade with the eu.

But actually, the uk hobbled the eu. So the example is wrong.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by wirrbel on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @03:18PM (#18972006)
For employees, collective bargaining is often much better than individual negotiation. I upped my salary for example by joining a unionized company, before I was at a non-unionized company and felt that I was better at negotiations than my peers.

Maybe there is a point for states to collectively bargain in trade agreements.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by pytester on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:34PM (#18971569)
When businesses move to Singapore, the reason is usually "they offered us an enormous tax break and/or subsidies".

In Dyson's case they probably got a sweetheart deal due to their brand.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by jimnotgym on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:17PM (#18971385)
What if I added that the original reason Dyson cited for moving to Singapore was the failure of Britain to join the euro?

That sounds like hypocrisy to me

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2000/nov/05/theobserver...

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by rchaud on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @05:18PM (#18973165)
I wish I could locate it now, but Dyson has penned a number of op-eds in the Guardian about the "skills gap" and how it's hard to hire in the UK because there aren't enough programmers, engineers etc.

In the comments, people were asking, "Have you considered increasing employee compensation?" I think we all know the answer to that.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by jashmatthews on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:09PM (#18971292)
FTAs aren’t magically more democratic. The loss of control of our own law was a major issue for New Zealand signing the Trans Pacific Partnership.

FTAs also bind countries to laws the citizens may oppose and even if changing a law is OK, it might still result in an expensive investor state dispute at a court of arbitration.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by rayiner on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:17PM (#18971377)
I don't know how FTA's work in New Zealand, but in the U.S., any treaty must be "implemented" by domestic legislation (except for in narrow cases where the subject matter falls within executive discretion to begin with). In the EU, by contrast, a regulation can be imposed on the citizens of a particular member nation even if those citizens' representatives oppose it.

To give an example, if the U.S. entered into an FTA requiring a $15 minimum wage, that provision would be ineffective until Congress passed a law making that the minimum wage. But Congress could impose a $15 minimum wage effective in Alabama, even if every Alabama Senator and Congressman opposed it. EU regulations are like the latter.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by fmajid on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @03:11PM (#18971942)
That's just false. CETA, the recent EU-Canada FTA had to be ratified by all national parliaments, and in the case of Belgium, by provincial parliaments as well.
Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by rayiner on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @03:24PM (#18972076)
The EU has multiple forms of laws, some of which require ratification by the national parliaments and some of which don't. EU Regulations are the equivalent of Acts of the United States Congress--they have automatic effect in all member states and override any conflicting national law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_(European_Union).

Treaties have their own intricacies, but they do not necessarily require ratification either. The EC initially asserted that CETA did not require ratification by the national governments, but backed down citing the "political situation": http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-7... (page 13).

I think many EU supporters really don't understand the sweeping powers of the EU. All the legal underpinnings are in place to turn the EU member countries into demi-sovereigns inferior to an EU government, just as happened to the U.S. states. They may be used sparingly now, but Brussels is getting bolder all the time.

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by jhanschoo on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:20PM (#18974376)
> The loss of control of our own law was a major issue for New Zealand signing the Trans Pacific Partnership.

Can I have a citation for this?

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by jashmatthews on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:47PM (#18974562)
Sure, I'll keep it tech related since it's HNews but: "...raises serious concerns about other countries’ sovereignty and the ability of national governments to set laws and policies to meet their domestic priorities."

https://www.eff.org/issues/tpp

Re:Dyson moves vacuum giant's HQ to Singapore by jhanschoo on Thursday January 24, 2019 @08:25AM (#18988396)
Thanks!