News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Things you should know about the Ottoman Janissaries by watwut on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @07:37AM (#18967807)
> The thing is, it's neither "bad" nor "good", it's just history. And in that context, the Janissaries are quite an interesting case because their history is filled with very extreme ups and downs.

History as is being interesting does not mean you cant make it sound better or worst then it was.

> Yes, they started out as a "slave soldier" unit in the thousands, made up of forced converts. But their efficiency on the battlefield quickly made them a very renowned unit, so renowned that over time even Muslim families tried to get their children to be recruited.

It is kidnapping out of original family that lost a son. The fact that kidnapped kid becomes valued soldier due to training and ideologization in isolation from original family and culture does not changes anything on that.

The unit leadership having a lot of power later on still changes nothing on loss of the original family, the boy being kidnapped and brainwashed/forced to be soldier.

Re:Things you should know about the Ottoman Janissaries by BeetleB on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @11:17AM (#18969337)
>The fact that kidnapped kid becomes valued soldier due to training and ideologization in isolation from original family and culture does not changes anything on that.

It's trivial to point out the converse: The fact that a soldier became valued due to training and ideologization is not changed by the fact that they were kidnapped.

Re:Things you should know about the Ottoman Janissaries by watwut on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @04:28PM (#18972676)
Thankfully, no one in this thread nor whole discussion claimed that they were not useful army. Just like in discussion of slavery most people agree that slaves earn money to master.

The original discussion was about whether article was in favor of some country or agenda. Answer is yes, the point of view of people who find institution beneficial to them and don't care about damage done to those kids nor to their families nor to their original societies.