News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by rossdavidh on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:26PM (#18961846)
As someone who has (once) written an opinion piece for the NYT, I wonder how much the published piece resembled the author's original text. My experience: https://www.rosshartshorn.net/stuffrossthinksabout/nyt_opini...
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by iamdave on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:47PM (#18962485)
I (once) wrote a Sports Illustrated opinion article years ago (similar situation to yours: made a comment on twitter to one of the popular talking heads, talking head took notice and replied, SI took notice, asked me to write something), your experience matched mine from the editing and review standpoint.

At first sitting back and reading the suggested edits and changes in place I had a similar first reaction as you did, but after doing the "walk away, do something else and come back to your writing later" thing, I found the opinion was still there though much less verbose.

Share that to say, the editorial process itself, even for opinion pieces-is rather....well... opinionated.

Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by rossdavidh on Monday January 21, 2019 @08:19PM (#18965193)
Very interesting to hear that. I guess I am not surprised. I felt that my basic opinion was there, but an opinion of theirs had been layered on top, in a very politically-oriented way. I don't know if this was conscious or not.
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by iamdave on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @02:52PM (#18971756)
I suspect this will be a take that someone is going to have a problem with, or maybe many do-but this is kind of the editor's job. Editorials while probably not the express opinion of the publication you're writing for does need to at least carry enough of an opinion of theme to stay consistent with readers expectations when they pick up $Publication_Weekly$.

Would it be nice to see if a publication just decided to run editorials contrary to or perhaps ones that eviscerated a viewpoint or position said publication has been known to hold-and entertain plurality for plurality's sake?

Probably. If that's what the readers have come to expect, probably.

But as a default condition of running a newspaper? I think senior editors like keeping their jobs too much for that.

Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by hopler on Monday January 21, 2019 @03:48PM (#18963484)
The NYT is called liberal, but more correctly it's pro-establishment/pro-government left-of-American-center.

They are personified by the Clinton family, yet are more pro-Bush than say pro-BernieSanders or pro-GaryJohnson.

With Trump's alternate-establishment weirdness and the extent polarization of modern US politics, the right wing is rejecting the NYT and thus pushing them farther left to maintain readership by catering to replacement readers.

Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by scabarott on Monday January 21, 2019 @04:39PM (#18963847)
This is astute and quite accurate (imho).
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by scabarott on Monday January 21, 2019 @05:28PM (#18964230)
This is really fascinating. Had no idea just an HN comment can get you an invitation to write a NYT op-ed. Is this usual? Have you written for a newspaper before or do they randomly source semi-anonymous internet commenters for opinion pieces?
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by rossdavidh on Monday January 21, 2019 @08:16PM (#18965173)
No, it has never happened to me before (and, I expect, will probably not happen again).
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by danieltillett on Monday January 21, 2019 @10:47PM (#18965866)
I have been through something similar (not with the NYT) with the same result. In fact I can't think of a single news story I have personal knowledge of that came out the media meat grinder showing any resembalance to what went in - pink slime more closely resembles a cow than these stories to the facts.
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by rossdavidh on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @10:58AM (#18969167)
Interesting, thanks for sharing.
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by lewis500 on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:59PM (#18962097)
wow this is brutal. thanks for sharing. I had mused on the idea of pitching them an opinion piece about my field, traffic, but not anymore.
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by rossdavidh on Monday January 21, 2019 @08:22PM (#18965207)
I should say, their check did clear (and I didn't even expect to get paid when I agreed to do it). So there's that.
Re:Letter in Response to Jan. 17 Article in The New York Times by kirion25 on Monday January 21, 2019 @07:04PM (#18964822)
Very interesting. Did you get feedback from NYT on this page?