As a user, I do agree that a "blanket opt in" button/ default checked checkbox is so pointless that it could as well be left out.
A EASILY DIGESTIBLE page explaining what data is stored and how it is used , with an agree button at the end (and separate opt-in for different sets of data/functionality) should be mandatory.
Emphasis on the easily digestible, because we all know that the "terms and contions" pages out there are constructed to be as obtuse and uninformative as possible to make users just skip them.
We need some general browser based auto script, so that websites don't get to ask, something like a do not track header, but one that was legally binding.
Until then I click accept on all the sites that I use on my phone, they can set all the cookies they want, as I use Firefox Sync, which erase all data whenever you press back or close the browser.
I worry that accepting cookies once, for one of these sites, will lead them to try and de-anonymize you, maybe even across private browsing windows, or different sessions. If you give them the right to basically fingerprint you, be assured that they will abuse it.
[1] https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/qookiefix
That is, no more “agree and continue” that isn’t accompanied by an equally prominent “continue without tracking”.
So, the market is so skewed that that is how presumably somewhat informed people perceive it?
I mean, I would think it is just obvious bullshit. There are plenty of businesses that sell you a service for money, and that is all they do, and this kind of regulation has exactly zero impact on them. The only problem is that they have to compete with others who simply mistreat their customers in order to be able to ask for less money--so it's about time that a level playing field is restored where it's obvious that anti-asshole regulation does not impact everyone.
I did not mean businesses would become unviable, just that everyone needs to change the way they present GDPR relevant information.
This has nothing to do with spying or misreading customers.
As a customer, I want to know what data a service stores and how it is used, without digging through pages of cryptic terms and services.
Informed consent is the keyword here.
Plenty of paid services share their data with third parties.
As a customer, I simply want my data to not be stored at all, unless I explicitly asked for it, in which case the consent is obviously implied.
> Plenty of paid services share their data with third parties.
And plenty of paid services don't. And those don't have to change anything. That's my point.
I doubt that you are going to explicitly ask sites to store your IP address, so how do you think that should be handled?
[1] IP address alone doesn't prove location, but it is evidence. The EU, for example, for requires for internet sales that you justify your choice of whose VAT to collect by providing two non-contradictory pieces of evidence for the location you chose. IP address can be one of those pieces. Billing address of the card used for the purchase can be another, and for most people that and IP address is enough.
Now, maybe it would be preferable to ask for permission in those cases as well (just put a checkbox in the order form?), but my point (though maybe not stated clearly enough) was not that I expect only data to be stored when I explicitly ask for it for be stored, but that it is only stored when I explicitly ask for something that necessarily requires the data to be stored. So, if I order some digital goods, it might be required that the shop stores my IP address, so that's probably OK. But my point is that that does not include the permission to use it for anything other than fulfilling the legal obligation, and most certainly not to also store my navigation behavior on their website, or to keep it once they don't need it for tax purposes anymore.
[1]: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...
[2]: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...
[3]: https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-data-protectio...
As for the amount of the fine, even if it is small in comparison with Google’s profits, it has to come from one employee’s budget. That one person will be strongly motivated to fix this.
https://noyb.eu/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/complaint-android...
CNIL agreed with the Complainant
It's interesting that this wasn't brought up to my employer in sweden. We had default data collection settings checked and in a separate view accessible by a similar "more options" toggle and it was deemed okay as long as we had a visible blanket opt-in checkbox and a link explaining the settings, how we use data, and how to adjust. Our regulators said it would be enough as the goal of GDPR is to make every use of data reasonably known, adjustable, and revokation with good faith toward the user. Yet here it seems France is arguing that it is about immediate showing of all settings to the user and that every website should tell in the user's face about every single configuration of data usage. It's possibly a good approach, idk, I feel it is a bit too annoying of a precedent and that they are nitpicking a bit.
I can't wait for this to fully play out. Regarding documentation and informing the user, I disagree with their findings entirely about the frustration of finding data usage info as all of Frances concerns were lost on me upon visiting https://safety.google/privacy/data/. To me it seems that google has made a good faith effort at least in documentation.