News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by wccrawford on Thursday November 11, 2010 @07:38PM (#1896023)
That article should have been left back in 1998.

Machines are not here to challenge us. They are created to make our lives easier. And that's what they do.

There's plenty of challenge out there for anyone who wants to find it. There's no need to keep everything difficult for those who want challenge.

Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by sofuture on Thursday November 11, 2010 @10:06PM (#1896360)
Did we read the same article? It wasn't about challenge nor was it a tirade against making things easy.
Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by silentbicycle on Thursday November 11, 2010 @08:40PM (#1896188)
What about when systems try so hard to make our lives easier that they actually get in the way? And, when people become so used to it that they don't see when things would be straightforward without that assistance?

Automated help is good, but who needs incompetent automated help?

Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by zeraholladay on Thursday November 11, 2010 @10:40PM (#1896441)
It doesn't work that way (inspire by Voltaire):

$ make life easier

Your life has been made easier: 70,500,000,000 dollars has been deposited into your bank account.

"There's plenty of challenge for anyone who wants to find it."

There are problems that haven't been solved yet and problems that can't be solved. Most problems can't be solved, since the majority of (our) problems are psychological (i.e. there are no axioms, assumptions, systems, etc to define this class of problem) -- the rest are impossible.

The problems that haven't yet been solved are actually interesting tho. The knowledge systems for these classes of problems are heuristic; i.e. a process of discovery and experience. The intention is often not to keep everything difficult but to keep everything knowable, which is contrary to the "don't make me think" principle of design.

Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by wccrawford on Friday November 12, 2010 @06:56AM (#1897367)
You can always re-solve a problem, if you want that challenge. The fact that someone else has solved it shouldn't stop you, if your goal is to have a challenge.
Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by zeraholladay on Friday November 12, 2010 @07:35AM (#1897434)
Consider the difference between math and engineering (at the undergrad level). Math majors learn to solve solved problems, since the solutions are instructive; that is, they could accept a solution as truth but proving it is true has a greater value. However, engineers need to accept a lot of mathematical truths since the occupation applies these truths.

Either way, both of these systems are instructive. You should be able to reverse a process and discover its discrete parts, if that's your goal.

Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by Mithrandir on Friday November 12, 2010 @01:54AM (#1896797)
I always run

$ man life

if I have a problem.

Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by wazoox on Friday November 12, 2010 @02:11PM (#1898768)

   $ man life  
   No manual entry for life
That's what I was afraid of.
Re:The dumbing-down of programming (1998) by angrycoder on Thursday November 11, 2010 @11:49PM (#1896562)
You realize you rallying against an article that is primarily about installing Linux and the joys of figuring things out. You realize you are on a site called hacker news right?