News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by smanek on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @09:19AM (#189546)
I don't belive that products should necessarily be held to any standard. Consumers should be informed about the safety of their product (known unsafe, unknown, certified safe, etc) and be allowed to make their own decisions.

Frankly, I think that I'm better at evaluating how much risk is acceptable to me than some government bureaucrat in Washington.

If a contractor offers to sell me a 800 square foot house, and I agree to buy it (knowing full well that it hasn't been certified and is smaller than legally required), how is that anyone's business but my own? I should be allowed to make my own decisions and live with the consequences of my own actions.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by Alex3917 on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:09AM (#189582)
>Frankly, I think that I'm better at evaluating how much risk is acceptable to me than some government bureaucrat in Washington.

Then you would love living in China. I guess going to a restaurant or grocery store where much of the food contains various poisons wouldn't bother you, since you're able to tell the difference.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mechanical_fish on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:16AM (#189592)
I was going to say: Relaxing the food regulations isn't some kind of brilliant new idea. It's been tried before, and in some countries it's still being tried. If the Chinese cat food stories from last year aren't scary enough for you, try reading Sinclair's The Jungle... or the slaughterhouse chapter of Fast Food Nation.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by byrneseyeview on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:08PM (#189713)
So, food safety is so important that the only way to assure it is to leave it up to a gigantic monopoly with no responsibility or accountability or incentive to pursue any goal other than it's own growth?

People act as if just saying that something must be done well is tantamount to agreeing that the government should do it -- but when I look at the Fed's record, I have to argue that if something is really important to you, you should do everything in your power to keep the government as far away as possible.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by pohart on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @02:05PM (#189823)
the parent isn't saying anything about it being so important, he is saying that not regulating isn't working is some particular cases.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by astine on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:35AM (#189610)
Sure, but you do realize that "The Jungle" was a deliberate load of muckraking bull? The whole book was about poor working conditions in American factories and to drive the point home, Sinclair described a guy falling into the lard vats and getting eaten. There was no truth to the health claims but the concept of eating people freaked out European importers so much that the US was forced to create FDA (Or its predecessor, I don't remember precisely.) The first reports found no evidence of Sinclair's claims.

The ironic thing is that Sinclair was hoping to spark a socialist revolution and improve the lives of the slaughterhouse workers. What happened was that the inspection agencies added to cost to the production process and actually lowered the standard of living for the workers.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by etal on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @05:18PM (#190009)
There was no single event that led to the creation of the FDA as we know it, but there was an interesting string of medical disasters during the first half of the 20th century that caused the scope of the laws and agency to creep:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fda#Early_history

An especially fascinating one was Elixir Sulfanilamide: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elixir_Sulfanilamide

For medicine, the incentives are all wrong for laissez-faire to prevent disaster. If you create a compound that you think will be useful in some way, it only takes a few tests to convince yourself and others that it's worth using. If it works safely in the general population, you're a hero and a millionaire; if you waste time on additional testing, your competition will beat you; and if your testing turns up some ambiguous data, you're stuck with the dilemma of whether to go forward with a product that has risks that the benefits may or may not outweigh. I've worked on medical devices; this last situation comes up constantly. Without detailed specifications that put the burden on the producers to prove safety and efficacy, what the producer thinks is due diligence is generally woefully inadequate.

(No comment on the state of agriculture back then, but these days the line between food and drug is getting blurry.)

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by apu on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:54AM (#189629)
[Citation Needed]
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mhb on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @11:26AM (#189668)
To refute a work of fiction?
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mechanical_fish on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:41PM (#189741)
A work of fiction that is nonetheless far more credible than this sentence:

There was no truth to the health claims...

From the Wikipedia entry on The Jungle:

After much persuasion from Sinclair as to the seriousness of the situation, Roosevelt agreed to send two men to investigate Sinclair's claims. The men the president chose, Charles P. Neill and James B. Reynolds, had both done investigative work for Roosevelt before, and were thought trustworthy...

Even though the meat packers had forewarning and time to clean up, the conditions Neill and Reynolds observed were described as "revolting;" the only claim left unsubstantiated by the report was the sensational claim that workers who had fallen into the giant lard vats were left and sold as lard.

Obviously, Wikipedia isn't an unimpeachable source. But it's better than one guy's unsourced opinion.

I note for the record that, confronted with a historical example from last year, a contemporary work of nonfiction (Fast Food Nation), and a work of muckraking fiction from 1906, we've now become curiously focused on debunking a single famous legend from the 1906 work. Because, of course, if Sinclair stretched a fact here and there out of revolutionary fervor, adulterated cat food must be perfectly good for cats.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by astine on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @01:16PM (#189779)
I don't know anything about "Fast Food Nation." I do know a little about Upton Sinclair. I can only argue with what I know.

Edit: You are right, it does seem that Wikipedia with some of my claims, but backs up the my points about the real focus and Sinclair's novel and it's real impact.

Either way, I prefer transparency to regulation.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by astine on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @11:23AM (#189662)
http://www.mackinac.org/article.aspx?ID=7229

(yes, this is a bit weak, but I have a job :P)

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by lbrandy on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @09:38AM (#189559)
> If a contractor offers to sell me a 800 square foot house, and I agree to buy it (knowing full well that it hasn't been certified and is smaller than legally required)

Because knowing 'full well' implies you knew what questions to ask. And requiring everyone to know all the questions they need to ask in every transaction is not only unreasonable but wasteful.

How many things need to be "fully" disclosed so that I can make an informed decision when buying milk? The whole purpose of regulation is to have a group of people who are asking those questions for us.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by smanek on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @09:44AM (#189564)
I think that private certification agencies (think consumer reports on steroids) could take the place of regulations.

I could either buy a gallon of milk that is certified by an agency I trust for a little more, or pay less (and ask my own questions) for an uncertified gallon.

And if a manufacturer chose not to disclose all relevant information, then I can choose not buy their product (and certification agencies will not certify it)

Not to mention that it isn't in any firm's economic interest to provide a patently unsafe product.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by pohart on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:04AM (#189577)
the problem is that no milk will be uncertified. There will be certain certifiers that will certify anything, and it will be extremely difficult for a buyer to tell the difference.

Look at something like eggs. People pay more for eggs because they are "free range", but free range just means that they have access to the range, not that they are capable of using that access.

And it is in firms interest to provide a patently unsafe product as long as not enough people are lost due to the unsafe product to counteract the savings.

without regulation it would be much harder to determine the cause of the problem.

If I am exposed to e-coli due to lettuce or spinach (each certified by a different agency), I won't know. I'll assume it was from my overeasy eggs or rare beef, or because the cook doesn't wash his hands. the farmer could go on selling tainted vegetables for quite a long time before the cause is found.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by smanek on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:18AM (#189594)
And people will choose to buy products verified by certifiers they trust. At least then you have a choice.

Consumer Reports has a far better record than the FDA.

Of course, as you state, there would be disreputable certifying agencies too but I could avoid them and only use long-running agencies with a good reputation.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by bmj on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:33AM (#189608)
I'm familiar with Salatin's writing (and practices), and I think his argument would be that if you have face-to-face transactions with the producer (Salatin won't ship his meat, for example--you must come to the farm to pick it up), you don't need a certifier because you are holding the producer accountable, and you can require that his processes are transparent.

Certainly you can argue that someone should do this for you, but Salatin is trying to shift the paradigm of how we produce and consume food.

EDIT: Corrected the mis-spelling. Duh.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by lbrandy on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:32AM (#189605)
> Consumer Reports has a far better record than the FDA.

Maybe that's because Consumer Reports has the benefit of leveraging all the work already done by the FDA. Let me be clear, though, you may be right that privatizing such things could work. It's just that your evidence isn't necessarily compelling.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by scott_s on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:08PM (#189712)
You're assuming the completely rational consumer, which does not exist.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mhb on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:21PM (#189723)
Not completely rational - minimally rational. And you're assuming the rational, non-corrupt government bureaucrat.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by Prrometheus on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:33PM (#189735)
>the problem is that no milk will be uncertified. There will be certain certifiers that will certify anything, and it will be extremely difficult for a buyer to tell the difference.

Interestingly enough, there is a substantial group of people that WANT to buy "uncertified" milk raw, straight from the cow. This is, unfortunately, illegal.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by LogicHoleFlaw on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @01:20PM (#189784)
In Wisconsin there was a bit of a brouhaha over the practice of "time-sharing" dairy cows. You see, while it's illegal to sell unprocessed milk, the owner of a cow is permitted to drink the raw milk.

Aha, found a link:

http://www.realmilk.com/milk-direct-program.html

Straight from the horse's... er, cow's... mouth.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by pohart on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @02:18PM (#189836)
I understand the risks of raw milk and want it. I also understand why we have it regulated. I would like to relax the regulation to allow me to get raw milk in some situations. but I don't want BigCo. selling it. BigCo. can't be trusted.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by Alex3917 on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:52AM (#189626)
With any luck your certification system will do for milk what US News & World Report did for colleges.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mynameishere on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @09:36AM (#189558)
The 900 square foot restriction seemed pretty odd, but I have a feeling it is designed to prevent trailer parks from moving in. If you have land in the country, that is the standard nightmare scenario.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by smanek on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @09:38AM (#189560)
If I buy a plot of land free and clear, shouldn't it be my right to put a trailer on it?
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mynameishere on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:35AM (#189611)
Yes and no.

I lived out in the country for a while and we had a few trailers near us. That's not a problem, and in appalachia, it's sometimes all the better people can do. The problem is trailer parks, which are sometimes okay, but sometimes are just rural ghettos, with crime and crack and meth and general bad behavior pouring out.

You have a few strategies to "keep up the neighborhood". The upper class strategy is to price out the poor people. The middle class strategy is zoning, which amounts to discrimination of various kinds. The results are pretty much the same. The fact the rich people get accidentally what middle class people have to get by fiat causes political confusion.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by Alex3917 on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @10:56AM (#189634)
There's no such thing as buying a plot of land free and clear, at least in the US. You're buying a set of rights, not the land itself. What those rights are is a function of local, state, and federal laws, the contract, and any restrictions put on the land previously.

That said, you can always build a barn and then put the trailer in the barn.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by noonespecial on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:58PM (#189761)
You're also not buying, you're leasing your land from the government. If you fail to pay your lease fees, the government will evict you and lease the land to someone else.

Yes they call it "taxes and zoning rules" but in practice it simply operates as a landlord charging rent and telling the tenant what they are and are not allowed to do with the landlord's property. If it walks like a duck...

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mechanical_fish on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:51PM (#189754)
Sure, if you don't mind the smell from the nuclear-powered mercury reclamation plant that I'm putting up next door.

Sorry about the noise, BTW, but the lot on the other side of yours is the perfect location for our CEO's private helipad.

(Incidentally, if you were really asking me about a shed, and not merely trying to bait us onto some slippery slope to anarchy... I rather like small cottages and would like to put one up myself. So I'd be pretty sympathetic at your zoning board meeting.

Ultimately, I'm guessing that zoning boards exist only because people were historically unwilling to just ask their neighbors first and abide by their preferences. And zoning boards can still be overridden if enough of your neighbors agree. It's called a "variance".)

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by lg on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @11:14AM (#189656)
maybe you could do that in the US, where the threat of lawsuits might keep people honest. but i wouldn't risk it.

seems like the problem this essay is pointing out is that the laws aren't fine-grained enough to distinguish between industrial farms and mom-and-pops. But probably, if there WERE such a distinction and mom-and-pops got off easy, corporate agriculture would bend over backwards to meet the technical definition. if the law said people can sell uncertified stuff on the farm premises, there'd be a little hen house in the back of every shoprite (or whatever), just like with the suv fuel efficiency restrictions. perhaps one way around that, though, is that since all corporations are (if anything) corporations, the law could single out food that's been handled by employees of registered corporations for special treatment. but who knows, they'd probably find a way around that too.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by timr on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @03:50PM (#189924)
I think you've made the critical argument: the law is a blunt instrument, because there are people who will abuse the intricacies of anything less.

This entire comment thread fascinates me, because it seems to consist of repeated jabs at "absurd" laws by cranky libertarians (or anarchists), followed by parries by people who can see reasonable arguments for said laws. Rarely does the debate rise to the level where it is acknowledged that sometimes good laws have unintended absurd consequences, and that just because a law prevents you from doing something you want to do, doesn't mean that the law is invalid (or an inappropriate intrusion of government into daily life).

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by peteg on Thursday May 15, 2008 @12:54PM (#190662)
It is more than the law is a blunt instrument. When it comes to food laws it is a blunt instrument whose only efficacious purpose is to raise the barrier to entry so high that small operators with truly clean and environmentally sound food can't compete (if they are even legal to begin with).
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by scott_s on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @09:59AM (#189572)
People would buy "known unsafe" products. They would presumably be cheaper, and some people would risk it. When the product is something like beef, very bad things would happen, and it would have potential to impact the rest of the community.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mhb on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @11:35AM (#189675)
Very bad things happen when you make regulations. The cost of all goods is higher because they all must comply. That means that there are people who can't afford the cost of the regulated goods who could eat more if the goods were available which met a lower regulatory threshold which was still acceptable to them.

Why do you assume that the current regulatory tradeoff between safety and cost is the right one for everyone?

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by scott_s on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:05PM (#189709)
Because the alternative leads to exploitation - both of the consumer and the worker.

Companies will cut costs any legal way they can. If you make it legal for them to be unsafe, they will be. The counter argument are market forces, but I don't think that works here. It assumes a completely rational consumer who understands the risk they are taking. We're not that rational, and generally don't understand the risks.

We didn't always have safety regulations. Bad things happened.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mhb on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:19PM (#189722)
Did you ever buy vegetables from a roadside stand or a neighbor's tomatoes? Did you rely on the existence of a government agency to ensure that they were safe to eat?

I can buy $5/lb tomatoes at Whole Foods or $2/lb tomatoes at Stop & Shop. Apparently Whole Foods perceives a market for food which isn't the lowest price possible. People will differentiate based on quality just as they do for safety. They don't need to be completely rational - they need to be minimally rational.

The point of the original article is that regulations lead to more problems - they are not just a response to, but also encourage the centralization of factory food production just like you read about in Fast Food Nation.

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by scott_s on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @12:22PM (#189725)
You're creating a false dichotomy.

Unreasonable regulations are a problem, yes. But there is a wide gulf between "let's ammend our regulations to be more reasonable" and "let's throw our regulations out entirely."

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mhb on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @01:01PM (#189764)
Perhaps. But the problem is that once reasonable regulations exist, they inevitably become unreasonable. No bureaucrat or agency wants to be the one who said no to the incremental regulation which would save just one more child despite the many who might benefit from doing nothing.
Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by mechanical_fish on Wednesday May 14, 2008 @01:35PM (#189801)
But the problem is that once reasonable regulations exist, they inevitably become unreasonable.

Only if your idea of effective political action is to start out arguing for a reasonable exception to a rule that unjustly prevents small-scale home butchering and end up thunderously denouncing the entire concept of "government".

Here's a simple rule that might help (aimed not so much at you, but at the author of the original article): Do not bring the word "firearms" -- to say nothing of an actual firearm -- into a conversation about the regulatory status of a small farm stand. Avoiding generic rants about "taxation" would also be good. Focus, people, focus!

Re:Everything I want to do is Illegal by xirium on Thursday May 15, 2008 @11:04AM (#190543)
I've seen a similar argument. If an employee agrees to work for less than a statutory minimum wage, does it matter? Yes, because it makes it harder for anyone else to get a better income.