News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by belorn on Sunday January 20, 2019 @03:11AM (#18951855)
Winder power is never just wind power. Looking at the power generation of example Germany we see a massive 75%+ use of wind power in good conditions, but then see it all replaced with coal + oil + gas when it is not.

Power generation is no longer based on demand. Weather sets the energy price, which dictate when it is economical to use fossil fuels. Wind is already at the point where the price per wat is fantastic, the environmental effect minimal, but if you include the need to infuse dirty energy when weather is not optimal the average wat start to look very different.

If we have to pick between wind + coal, or only nuclear, the carbon emission will favor nuclear. An other version is wind + fewer nuclear plants and lower energy usage during low wind conditions, but there is only so much that the energy usage drop when prices goes up. There is also a bunch of wind + "battery" research, but I have not heard of any national power grid fully investing in that.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by benj111 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:26AM (#18952526)
I'm not sure why you're being downvoted. You make some reasonable points.

I would say though, in the short term, we could stand to increase renewables massively with out needing to solve the storage problem, virtually every watt of installed capacity we add is directly offsetting dirty producers.

Grid scale battery storage is just starting to be implemented, theres also hydro, and 'smart' grid solutions. Whether any of this turns out to be a silver bullet I don't know.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by belorn on Sunday January 20, 2019 @07:49AM (#18952803)
Yes. Short term renewables supplement existing grid and reduce the average pollution. It is good to reduce the problem and should be used so that on good conditions it will practically take over all production. However it can not replace the polluting producers on its own, who seem to have started to switch operation to mostly when there is not enough renewables to supply the demand (marginal costs like fuel + investment vs the so-called merit order).

Nuclear could operate just like the dirty producers and only operate when the combined wind and solar is too low for the demand, which would further reduce the environmental impact, but the massive investment needed in nuclear makes the economics of it a bit complex and I have not read if the marginal costs of nuclear operations make this a viable tactic. It would however reduce the nuclear pollution down to the gaps where wind and solar is not enough.

That leaves future tech solutions. Smart grids sounds great, through I do not know how big part of it is a political issue or technical problem. Just getting the steel industry to focus operation on energy producing peaks seems to be a major challenge, and they already have the incentive that the energy get cheaper if they do so. Converting hydro to create burst of power rather than continuously is also something very interesting but has also both political and technical issues to solve. Then we have different from of battery ideas, all from pumping water to different heat capturing concepts, through I think that is even further away form being implemented on a large scale.

The article talks about the proposed subsidy, and this is where I think we need to think about the grid as a whole. If the goal is to fill the gap when wind and solar can't supply the demand then the discussion should not be renewable vs nuclear. It is very possible that the specific subsidy is a bad tactic and they would be better served by trying to narrow the gap with even more wind and solar, but then we need data to show that existing dirty producers are preferred over nuclear in order to fill the remaining gap. That to me is a hard sell, but I am open to be convinced :).

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by benj111 on Sunday January 20, 2019 @08:28AM (#18952938)
"Nuclear could operate just like the dirty producers and only operate when the combined wind and solar is too low for the demand"

Not quite. Nuclear isn't that dispatchable.

In general I agree though, short term we should be using all tools at our disposal, long term depends on how energy storage etc works out.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by DennisP on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:21AM (#18952510)
Solar seems like a decent pair with nuclear. Use nuclear at the level of night-time load, solar covers the extra daytime demand, and any remaining discrepancy you cover with either storage or extra nuclear, whichever is cheaper.

A couple years ago MIT had a simulator online that let you try out different grid energy combinations to see their total cost, and this was the cheapest I came up with.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by froindt on Sunday January 20, 2019 @11:41AM (#18953858)
Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by DennisP on Sunday January 20, 2019 @12:06PM (#18954046)
That's not it but it looks interesting!

The one I mentioned let you pick different proportions of energy sources for the entire U.S. grid, and told you how much it would cost, the carbon impact, etc.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by pytester on Sunday January 20, 2019 @06:29AM (#18952541)
>Looking at the power generation of example Germany we see a massive 75%+ use of wind power in good conditions, but then see it all replaced with coal + oil + gas when it is not.

The last time I looked they were importing power from abroad when it's not, which usually meant pulling in excess power from French nuclear plants.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by belorn on Sunday January 20, 2019 @08:01AM (#18952850)
Usage vs production is one of areas where I have had a hard time to get good data. I mostly base my own understand on https://www.electricitymap.org/?page=country&solar=false&rem... and https://www.energy-charts.de/power.htm?source=all-sources&ye...

That said, there is a lot of import/export in Europe on the energy grid.

Re:Carbon emissions and costs of subsidizing New York nuclea... by yk on Sunday January 20, 2019 @08:39AM (#18952979)
Thing is nuclear can not be only nuclear. Or actually it can, but then you should compare it to other science fiction tech like solar in orbit, because the kind of reactors that can be steered to demand has just not been designed yet.