News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gunk: Modern front end and syntax for Protocol Buffers by djur on Friday January 18, 2019 @10:44PM (#18945203)
I'm not seeing what makes this "modern". proto3 is only a few years old and nothing about it strikes me as unusually archaic. Protobuf in general isn't that much older than Go. I can see why Go-compatible syntax would be attractive to Go developers, so maybe that should be in the description rather than "modern"?
Re:Gunk: Modern front end and syntax for Protocol Buffers by denormalfloat on Saturday January 19, 2019 @01:57AM (#18945725)
There is a semi-consensus that Proto3 was created to be compatible as Go basic types. Making Go types from Protos, or Proto types from Go is what is being entertained as modern.
Re:Gunk: Modern front end and syntax for Protocol Buffers by djur on Saturday January 19, 2019 @01:50PM (#18948507)
Proto3 has features (discussed elsewhere in these comments, like oneOf) that aren't present in Go's type system. I'm not clear on why constraining it so it's more narrowly compatible with a particular implementing language is more modern.

It would be useful to see an example of the workflow of using this tool compared with the equivalent workflow while using protoc. That would be a selling point, while "modern" is just a sticking point.

Re:Gunk: Modern front end and syntax for Protocol Buffers by inciampati on Saturday January 19, 2019 @04:05AM (#18946103)
The compatibility is not just with Go types, but any C structure compatible types in any language.