News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by kiba on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:42PM (#1894545)
I think we're finding out the absurdity of copyright and patents by forcing these kind of concepts to face the redutio ad absurdum of the day, which are technologies like 3D printing.

On the other hand, the past is full of interesting example of PATENT FAIL like Whitney's failure to enforce the cotton gin, but he got rich with producing munition for the US army, while at the same time inventing the concept of interchangeable parts.

We saws that American writers hating their competitors from England because of the massive piracy of British literature leading domination in the American literacy market. Some English writers managed to make more money from the American than he could collect via some amount of royalty years. It was only when large publishing house finally change their tune that the American finally recognize British copyright.

We also saw James Watt's partner using the parliament to extend patents for Watt's steam engine invention. This waste to tremedous wasteful effort from Watt suing various people for violating his patents. In reality, Watt was just one of the many steam engine inventors, who hampered other steam engine inventors' ability to make a living and build on top of his work. He also ironically got hampered by some other guy's patent, forcing him to use inferior design for his steam engine.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:55PM (#1894595)
There's a great book about all of this, "Against Intellectual Monopoly." [1]

There's an interesting bit about the English/American writer thing you mention, specifically Dickens. From chapter two:

    The amount of revenues British authors received up front 
    from American publishers often exceeded the amount they 
    were able to collect over a number of years from 
    royalties in the UK. Notice that, at the time, the US 
    market was comparable in size to the UK market.

    More broadly, the lack of copyright protection, which 
    permitted the United States publishers’ “pirating” of 
    English writers, was a good economic policy of great 
    social value for the people of United States, and of no 
    detriment, as the Commission report and other evidence 
    confirm, for English authors. Not only did it enable the 
    establishment and rapid growth of a large and successful 
    publishing business in the United States; also, and more 
    importantly, it increased literacy and benefited the 
    cultural development of the American people by flooding 
    the market with cheap copies of great books. As an 
    example: Dickens’ A Christmas Carol sold for six cents 
    in the US, while it was priced at roughly two dollars 
    and fifty cents in England. This dramatic increase in 
    literacy was probably instrumental for the emergence of 
    a great number of United States writers and scientists 
    toward the end of the nineteenth century.
Arguments about intellectual property now seem to always focus on the ability of the author to make money, and not about the basic reason that the concept of IP was created: it was a gift from society to creators to both help them and encourage the enrichment of society at large. The dramatic rise in UGC demonstrates that 'creators gonna create' anyway, so the deal makes less and less sense for society to keep up.

There's also a part in the book about the steam engine stuff, too, but this is already getting long...

1: http://levine.sscnet.ucla.edu/general/intellectual/against.h...

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by alanh on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:16PM (#1894858)
UGC is one thing, but without financial backing largely enabled by IP, it’s hard to imagine the most epic and polished movies & games would still be made.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:19PM (#1894880)
A great recent counterexample to this is Avatar, right? Super expensive, all financed by Cameron, right? Made tons of cash.

There will probably be less made, you're right. But they'll still get made.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by jimbojohn on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:21PM (#1894891)
But he recouped the money through charging people to see the movie. Not a counter-example at all.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:45PM (#1894968)
He did. It was also available to download for free on the Internet.

"No IP" does not mean "You can't charge for things." Enough people would rather go to a movie theater than get on Bittorrent that he made his money back.

Side note: I was one of those people. I wear Pirate Bay tshirts around, I'd throw out all IP law if I was in charge... but I did pay money to go to the theater to see Avatar. Going to the theater and getting that crazy huge screen, great sound system, and (maybe) the 3D was totally worth it.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by teamonkey on Thursday November 11, 2010 @03:29PM (#1895113)
The fact that it worked for one movie does not mean that it would work any other movie.

The hook with Avatar was that it was a spectacle deliberately designed to be seen in 3D on the biggest screen possible, to the extent that there's very little point not seeing it in a movie theatre.

It's a unique example and its impact (and profitability) would be lessened by a) competition by similar movies and b) greater adoption of home 3D hardware.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @03:49PM (#1895181)
Absolutely. There's no question that without IP, things would be different. The real question is if it would be a better or worse world.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by alanh on Thursday November 11, 2010 @06:24PM (#1895798)
In my mind, the answer is “better” if we also no longer need to worry about money (that is, a post-capitalist system). I’m not sure about the meantime.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @07:11PM (#1895941)
The book that I cited up there in my huge post actually lays out a pretty compelling argument that it even works within capitalism.

IP is a pretty new concept. Things have worked really well for a long time without it.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by teamonkey on Thursday November 11, 2010 @08:58PM (#1896220)
Yes, capitalism is a pretty new concept also. The two go hand-in-hand.

But never before in history have we been able to copy media ad infinitum for practically zero time, cost and effort. It's always required time, an educated, talented person to copy, or resources that had a real cost.

In the case of the 3D printer the only real expense is the plastic used to print the object, which is awesome only for those who manufacture the materials.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @09:32PM (#1896283)
Actually, it's pretty funny: the materials are the only place where they make their money. 3D printers are sold on a total razor and blade model, the machine manufacturers make 70% of their money from materials, and something like 5% on actual machines.

Then things like this happen: http://open3dp.me.washington.edu/2009/10/sugar-sugar-powder/

> The cost of this mix is $0.15 – $0.30 per pound!

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by Yzupnick on Thursday November 11, 2010 @06:05PM (#1895730)
>Enough people would rather go to a movie theater then get on Bittorrent

True, but i guarantee that Movie theaters would rather get on Bittorrent rather than pay millions of dollars in fees to James Cameron. The only thing stopping them is IP laws.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by alanh on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:51PM (#1894991)
Fascinating his wife’s movie, released the same year, actively litigated those who shared the movie online.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by wazoox on Thursday November 11, 2010 @03:01PM (#1895020)
Patents and copyright were a tremendous progress back in the 1700s when you need a "privilege" from the King to undertake about anything. Nowadays they're just some sort of fossilized roadblock from the past. Here's another fine example of this sorry state of the matter.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by alanh on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:38PM (#1894532)
This & P2P mesh “internet” are Doctorow’s favorite topics, if his stories are any indication
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by daeken on Thursday November 11, 2010 @01:50PM (#1894761)
My favorite of his short stories on the subject, Printcrime: http://craphound.com/overclocked/Cory_Doctorow_-_Overclocked...
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by tbrownaw on Thursday November 11, 2010 @03:21PM (#1895080)
Next step: automated home chemistry setups that turn near-arbitrary feedstock containing the right elements into soap, food, shampoo, beer, plastic resin, ...
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by camiller on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:09PM (#1895262)
..., Rohypnol, viagra, duct tape, ...
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:07PM (#1894399)
This whole copyright vs 3D printing thing is interesting, but the bigger, more important battle right now is actually patents vs. 3D printing.

The entrenched players in the industry have large patent portfolios, and this hurts the ability of projects like the RepRap to actually make improvements. We probably could have had all of these kinds of projects years ago, but the patents are only now starting to run out...

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by kiba on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:31PM (#1894508)
What evidences to suggest that these kind of projects didn't start because of patents?
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:39PM (#1894533)
First of all, IANAL.

Secondly, it would appear to me that MakerBot, for example, is pretty blatantly infringing on the FDM patents that Stratasys has. Those are about to run out Real Soon Now, though, so they're probably fine.

Third, the industry has shaped up the way that it has because of patents. There's a reason there's 14 different ways to do 3D printing. Yeah, some are better at some things than others, but realistically, we'd really have like 3 or 4 processes if there were no patents to force new hardware companies to reinvent the wheel all the time.

The fact that there's pretty much a 1-1 mapping between companies and processes suggests that it's difficult to start a business in this area, due to the large amount of capital needed to invent a new way of doing things.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by kiba on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:51PM (#1894577)
It does seem to me that new companies can't start, but I doubt somebody really interested in 3D printing research would really care?
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by steveklabnik on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:59PM (#1894607)
But we'd move forward faster if we had both startups and university research working on the problem.

I'm not saying that it quashes all of it, just that it's set back personal fabrication 25 years.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by kiba on Thursday November 11, 2010 @01:25PM (#1894691)
I'm not saying that it quashes all of it, just that it's set back personal fabrication 25 years.

Forgive me for my historical ignorance, is there any sort of open hardware movement 25 years ago?

If not, than replication technology 25 years ago would probably have a different character.

Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by elai on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:59PM (#1895014)
The parallels between the makerbot/reprap and the Altair 8800 in 1975 is very interesting. It couldn't do much, but it marked the start of the "personal" computer era. Microsoft made it's first piece of software for that machine.
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by bld on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:36PM (#1895373)
Re:Copyright vs. 3D printing by clistctrl on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:49PM (#1895427)
I would assume it would be almost exactly the same as digital media works today, while it is best to manufacture things in mass quantities a CD of the machines components will be shipped with the dish washer. The opening of the box will imply acceptance of the licensing agreement for the machine. An alternative, is you get access to the washing machine support site with the warranty number included. You would be purchasing the right to the design, and maybe 1 working copy of a part at a time.

if we ever got to the point where it makes more sense for you to manufacture the entire product at home, then the concept would be the same. You are purchasing the rights to manufacture 1 working copy. If you give the files to another person who uses them, technically they are breaking the law.

Of course I think this is all kind of ridiculous. However the only solution I can think of to combat piracy is to crowd source the funding to the creation of new plans, and release the product in the public domain.