He had a quiet programming position in a large company that gave him time to work on personal projects. Among other things he volunteered at the local schools teaching "fun" math. I guess I'm just agreeing with you about finding something that inspires you and go with it.
I mean, if you're interested in astrophysics, you shouldn't go to a school where the Physics department is focused on nuclear physics!
He didn't care about the status of having a PhD
He didn't need a PhD to advance his career
He was having fun doing math stuff anyway
While I appreciate your brother's personal choice, to each their own after all. There is quite a lot of merit in your PhD advisor helping you in choosing a problem. That being said, good advisors provide students with an array of good problems out of which the student can choose one they are the most passionate about. This is what happened with me, I was provided with around 7 different choices to make. In the end, I chose 2 of them even though I wanted to chose 3 more but couldn't because of lack of time.
Links:
http://content.algebraicgeometry.nl/2017-2/2017-2-007.pdf
https://projecteuclid.org/download/pdfview_1/euclid.ecp/1508...
Look for my name (Thomas / Tom Price) on these pages:
https://web.archive.org/web/20170121000748/https:/wwwmath.un...
https://www2.math.binghamton.edu/p/seminars/arit/arit_spring...
https://www2.math.binghamton.edu/p/seminars/arit/arit_fall20...
https://www2.math.binghamton.edu/p/seminars/arit/arit_fall20...
As an aside, your work on numerical cohomology appears to have been useful for a new result pertaining to lattices. Given the authors of the followup work it's likely helpful for the study of lattices in post-quantum cryptography.
There are plenty of people who devote several years of their life to studying, and must pay not only their living expenses but tuition fees as well. In my opinion, those are the people who you should be asking “how did you manage this”.
I am afraid that sounds curmudgeonly, but I have also seen students shoot themselves in the foot because they decided they didn't need a class for their not very well informed goals.
Nah, it's totally possible for newbies to pick high-level long-term goals.
This can be something like "I want to teach my computer to tell apart dogs and cats", or "I want to create a website where people can buy and sell yarn." From there, Google searches can direct someone towards concepts and various methods of learning them.
I mean, you can disagree all you want, but this is in fact how many people learn things.
Of course this is in the context of choosing research problems to strive towards in math. If you tasked yourself with solving an open problem in math, it's more likely than not that, without any collaboration, you'd have no idea how to even work towards the goal due to all the unknown unknowns. If your goal is something concrete that can be augmented with mathematics, then yes I agree that goal setting can be useful. It doesn't take a volume of missing domain knowledge to develop that kind of goal.
People just assume learning math is the same as learning everything else. That is not even remotely true.
> everything else that’s worth learning: hard!
I disagree. I’ve learned many things worth learning that are not hard at all, but to each their own.
Like, if you are into Rubik's cubes, that's going to make learning group theory a lot more fun and motivating.
I have actually found people to be very different in this regard.
For instance, I work in data science and a lot of my peers like to learn about new techniques by applying them to real problems or working with datasets and exploring.
I don't like that approach. I always like to learn the theory of something before using it.
Similarly, I had the goal of learning math for statistics and general relativity among other subjects.
But my desire to have a deep understanding, ended up with me essentially learning the equivalent an undergraduate math degree and selected graduate level topics.
In my case, just learning in a bottom up way with maybe a slight direction would have been sufficient.
I think maybe the most likely outcome, if they were really motivated and somewhat capable, is that they learn lots of mathematics well—but maybe not quite to, "... through graduate level" (that phrasing is a bit ambiguous though; self-teaching 'up to' graduate level is definitely doable).
I personally did work myself up to the graduate in math during the last two years of High School & first year of college. I was motivated by exploring ideas and gaining knowledge. I would guess that each person has a somewhat unique motivation strategy. Maybe solving problems gets some people doing stuff. I'm sure simply learning stuff can motivate others. Probably each person has to experiment to discover what works for them - I would pick up a calculus book and read it - well, I'd skim repeatedly and then read in depth, solving a few problems. Math is difficult, of course, so having a bit of patience with your until it gets the ideas on it's own is probably necessary.
...how in the world did you manage to do this? Did you actually self-study, or were you placed in a gifted program? Self-studying all of undergraduate mathematics is more impressive than actually studying all of it in a four year classroom setting. Doing so as a teenager is amazing.
The most gifted person I've ever known in mathematics is actually a physicist who entered Harvard at 16. He was already taking undergraduate math courses at 13/14 and had mastered all the undergraduate material by the first semester of his undergraduate degree. For the remaining years of his undergraduate degree he took graduate math courses.
But in order to do that he needed to not only be gifted; he was placed in a program for extremely gifted kids sponsored by Stanford University from his preteen years. I don't think your anecdote is a great comparison for the OP's expectations (or for calibrating advice they'd benefit from).
I read quite a bit on my own, I took some courses at UCLA through a high school scholars program (including the undergraduate honors seminar). The entirety of the undergraduate program might be a slight exaggeration but I was ready for graduate level courses when I got to Berkeley.
I think going through the material requires determination, not necessarily being extremely gifted. But then, it seems like people at someone's gone through a bunch material say by that fact they're gifted. Thus having done this, one is tautologically gifted.
I've never tested at the extremely gifted level but I'm doubtful of single-measures of intelligence regardless.
Edit:
I don't think your anecdote is a great comparison for the OP's expectations (or for calibrating advice they'd benefit from).
Neither of us know the OP. It's kind of up to them to calibrate what process works for them. Scanning a lot of math until I found good, clear explanations worked well for me.
Indeed, speaking only for myself, I don't think that I had the self discipline to carry through with such a plan as a teenager. I needed the classroom environment to learn math & physics, which became my college majors. At the same time, I was able to teach myself programming and electronics quite easily for some mysterious reason. And I ended up combining all of those things in grad school.
Also, I only had access to the books and resources of a typical suburb with a decidedly anti-intellectual culture. The officials at my high school refused to offer a calculus course because they said it would be "elitist."
For example, (since I don't really have much time)
1. Topology (book by Munkres)
2. Real Analysis and Measure Theory (book series by Stein Shakarchi)
3. Algebra (book by Aluffi)
4. Linear Algebra (book by Friedberg Insel)
5. Measure Theoretic Probability (book by Cinlar)
6. Differential Geometry (book Smooth Manifolds by Lee)
7. Numerical Analysis (book by Quarteroni)
8. Set Theory and Propositional Logic (books by Goldrei)
This is what one will mainly learn in a strong undergrad/grad math program. Once this is done, then there are different tracks to follow.
I was questioning why the OP wants to self-study an undergrad math curriculum to begin with.
It's probably not to become a pure mathematician. So I suggested, instead of creating a massive goal of getting through a collection of books just for the sake of being a completionist, to have a concrete personal goal. Otherwise, people can throw books "you have to read" at you until the cows come home. Especially since this person is talking about applied math.
But your advice has a point, just going through books mindlessly is not motivation enough/ can lead to wandering. And it is always good to have specific tasks at hand. Like, solving a particular ordinary differential equations numerically.
Also, unfortunately, its not the recommended order to learn them in.
1. Find a thing you want to make. 2. Find out how to make it. 3. Try to make it. 4. Learn the skills that previously prevented you from making it.
Unlike programming, mathematics isn’t something you can pick up in a weekend.
EDIT: Now that I think about it, you can probably bang your head against, say, Lang, for two years, “digesting” a big chunk of it, earning you the bragging right of “working yourself up to graduate level math”. That won’t give you the breadth of a good bachelor of mathematics, and it certainly won’t prepare you for quality research.
> be able to write up a compelling
Can someone clarify what this means?
It's all well and good to want to cover undergraduate math courses. When you are actually enrolled in a university, you will have enough inertia and motivation to complete the courses.
However, when you are self-studying you are doing it all on your own. It's hard to be as thorough and cover everything.
And so I ask, what really is your goal here? You don't have to learn everything about mathematics, because that is in fact impossible.
My advice is to FIRST construct a bunch of projects, tasks or goals that require knowledge.
It could be something like (a) implement a machine learning algorithm to do X from scratch (b) implement a simple physics engine (c) try to verify a number theory conjecture (d) be able to solve all the exercises in a book (e) be able to write up a compelling description/theorem/problem in math (d) numerically solve the quantum mechanics equations of a certain system
Spend some time on material that will inspire you first to help get these goals. Numberphile on YouTube, or any of Brady Haran's videos, is a good place to start. But make the goals your own and make them personal.
Math is not a spectator's sport. Make sure to DO mathematics, not just LEARN mathematics.