Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by politician on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:39PM
(#18934902)
What do you think about a radar approach like Google's Project Soli?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by guscost on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:00PM
(#18935064)
I work on the software side, so I can't really comment with authority, but this looks like it could be an interesting lower-frequency/lower-power approach to active sensing. From the preview site, it seems like the "resolution" of this model may be too low to separate and count a crowd of people. However I'll forward this on to the hardware team just in case, thanks!
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by weej on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:00PM
(#18935063)
Isn't Soli more for natural user interface (NUI) detection via radar wave disruptions? I'm not sure it would provide very granular detection and he'd have a lot of false positives.
I was thinking more in terms of lidar tracking of people. It's been around for nearly a decade and works quite well.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by politician on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:18PM
(#18935206)
Right, Soli is built for NUI. However, it does seem like it might fit this use case as well:
Distance - I'd imagine that the distance from the top of a door frame to the top of the head of the average shopper is roughly equivalent to the distance from the Soli device to someone's hands.
Software - The Soli hardware streams radar contacts to software trained to separate and classify them, not too unlike the approach that Density is already using.
Benefits over a CV approach might come in power usage and lower complexity in the contact classification software.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by guscost on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:04PM
(#18935103)
Unfortunately, as far as I know LIDAR is still prohibitively expensive for this. Someone did invent a solid-state LIDAR system recently, which seems like a good sign.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by weej on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:23PM
(#18935238)
Fair point. I was solely thinking from a technical solution not the practicality around deployment. My employer has biased my bubble on thought process. "Oh, yes, this is easy to solve, and I see it on campus (Disney - imagineering office).