Re:A Harvard Astronomer on the Interstellar Object ‘Oumuamua
by gus_massa on Wednesday January 16, 2019 @09:21PM
(#18927738)
> Why should we favour the first one?
If confirmed, which of the following two will get to the first page of all newspapers in the world:
* Scientists find a rock in space
* Scientists find a alien starship in space
The "default" selection is the other, unless someone provides overwhelming evidence.
> In this case, when we discovered a new, weird and unexplainable phenomenon,
It's probably a rock with some ice.
> Well, according to the Fermi Paradox,
The Fermi paradox starts from the assumption that we should expect a big number of advanced civilization in the Milky Way, but we really don't have the smallest cue about how the number should be. We have a estimations from millions of millions to much less than one. We just don't know. We only know that we didn't find an alien civilization yet. We didn't even find alien life yet. So you can't use the Fermi paradox as a proof or supporting evidence that an unknown object has alien origin.
If confirmed, which of the following two will get to the first page of all newspapers in the world:
* Scientists find a rock in space
* Scientists find a alien starship in space
The "default" selection is the other, unless someone provides overwhelming evidence.
> In this case, when we discovered a new, weird and unexplainable phenomenon,
It's probably a rock with some ice.
> Well, according to the Fermi Paradox,
The Fermi paradox starts from the assumption that we should expect a big number of advanced civilization in the Milky Way, but we really don't have the smallest cue about how the number should be. We have a estimations from millions of millions to much less than one. We just don't know. We only know that we didn't find an alien civilization yet. We didn't even find alien life yet. So you can't use the Fermi paradox as a proof or supporting evidence that an unknown object has alien origin.