EDIT: Now that I think about it, I also have several repos where I have changes that I never intend to ever commit them, because they are development conveniences for me personally.
I'm a JS dev mainly working in React on a web app with a backend team using PHP. Often I'll be working on a branch with maybe 2 or 3 people and I often end up working on a few things at a time. Say I'm working on a feature, and I notice some bug I'll fix that and then get on with my feature. Once I go to commit I pretty much always do a 'git add . -p' and I very rarely want to add all the files I've worked on!
Even things like switching a config file to use a service like apiary where I don't want to commit my change to the config to use apiary.. Or change to my webpack config for testing, etc.
I've used Perforce, SVN and Git and the whole 'staging' area thing always felt very natural to me. Here are the files you've edited, which ones want to be commited? It gives me a second chance to go through and check everything before I've commited, and often that stops me leaving in any odd comments or debug code.
Surely, most of the time when you go to commit, it's all the files you've changed?