Re:Show HN: Critique my pro football (NFL) data webapp
by wtn on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @05:37PM
(#1892040)
Thanks for the user-defined groups idea. I probably won't get to it for a while (in favor of adding simpler functionality), but it could be really useful for frequent users or in conjunction with user-generated Protovis charts.
I probably need to rework the fumbles page, both because the page is presently showing incomplete data and because the presentation could be more intuitive.
I thought it was easiest to have all of that data on one page rather than to have separate pages for fumbles and fumble recoveries. Fumbles fall under a weird special teams / misc category of stats; offensive players often recover, plus there are weird cases where defenders recover the ball and then fumble themselves.
The postseason data is in the todo list. I just need to add the relevant control to the search filter form.
passing: yards/attempt and yards/completion could both be included, right now it looks like avg. represents yds/attempt
postseason: would be cool to see player stats aggregated by individual post-seasons (right now you can see post-season games, and season totals, but not post-season totals)
agree with another comment that it would be useful to be able to select multiple player-years (maybe the same player across years, maybe different players the same year or across years) to compare
similarly, would be interesting to create user-defined groups of teams or players that could be sorted on different dimensions (compare 2007 pats, 2004 colts, 2000 rams, 1998 vikings, etc.)
fumbles as both an offensive stat and defensive stat is a bit unintuitive to me, also some of the players who show up have zeros in every fumble category; fumbles recovered could be part of defense (along with ff)
overall it is very smooth, but i am not sure what i would user it for (and i am a huge sports fan, watch multiple nfl games every week, etc.). i agree with other comments that a fantasy angle could be helpful (e.g. input your league's scoring system, sort each position's players by points/week, season).