News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by ck2 on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @10:29AM (#1890572)
I approve a warning 1000% - it's not like they are stopping you from exporting.

This will slow down my AOL-using friends who gave away all their contact info to Facebook and now I get pelted with spam from Facebook using my name and list of friends (and I don't even have a Facebook account).

Google has never spammed me or share my name and location, Facebook does it all the time, pick who's more evil.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by axavier on Thursday November 11, 2010 @08:33AM (#1893748)
http://techcrunch.com/2009/10/26/orkut-slows-hemorraging-to-...

Relevant quote from Google:

"Mass exportation of email is not standard on most social networks - when a user friends someone they don’t then expect that person to be easily able to send that contact information to a third party along with hundreds of other addresses with just one click"

Lets recap:

1. Users use data exporter en masse to abandon Orkut.

2. Google breaks the exporter. Supposedly a bug, coincidentally when people are actually now using it.

3. Google changes the exporter so emails are no longer included.

4. Google says social networks shouldn't be expected to allow mass email exportation.

5. 12 months pass

6. Google breaks the gmail exporter to Facebook. Social networks apparently are now expected export all e-mails. Press eats it up.

Look, I'm not arguing that email exporting should or shouldn't be allowed. I don't really want my friends giving my email to Farmville so they get a golden banana, but it's not the end of the world. What I don't get though, is people talking about this like Google is some godly force of good, championing the rights of users against the evil Facebook.

Please. Google is getting scared, and made a calculated (albeit hypocritical) business decision to try and slow down Facebook's growth. The rest of this is BS PR spin and Techcrunch sensationalism to fan the drama fires.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by DjDarkman on Saturday November 13, 2010 @05:50AM (#1900685)
The GMail exporter is not broken, it just warns you.
Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by kmavm on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:36AM (#1890872)
> This will slow down my AOL-using friends who gave away all their contact info to Facebook and now I get pelted with spam ...

Right; there are practical usability problems with allowing willy-nilly access to your contact list. Some of your contacts have now given your email address to a company with which you never wanted to have a relationship.

Which is precisely Facebook's reasoning for not providing an API to download your friends' email addresses. Thanks for providing a concrete reminder of the legitimacy of this choice.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by ewjordan on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @02:14PM (#1891467)
Right; there are practical usability problems with allowing willy-nilly access to your contact list. Some of your contacts have now given your email address to a company with which you never wanted to have a relationship.

This is a red herring. Facebook lets me choose whether my friends can give away literally anything else that's part of my Facebook presence to third party apps. In fact, there's a strong recommendation that I allow as much access to apps as possible, in the name of a "more social" experience. They let apps that I've never used spam me daily, I don't really get the sense that they care whether they force me into relationships with companies I have no interest in, as long as it happens within Facebook.

Why should I not get to decide whether to expose my e-mail address? If I want to, I'm allowed to set my e-mail address to "Everyone" visibility in my profile, literally the only thing I'm not allowed to do is expose it via the API.

That's a very deliberate choice, and maybe I'm a cynic, but it strikes me as mighty telling that the lack of API access to the e-mail part of the social graph is just about the only barrier in the way of Google being able to reconstitute the entire Gmail intersection of Facebook's social graph (Facebook UIDs don't suffice, because Google can't match these to e-mail addresses without the users explicitly doing so for them).

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by falcolas on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @04:35PM (#1891872)
This makes the assumption you already have a relationship (an account) with Facebook. If you do not have an account with Facebook, you do not have this control. kmavm's post indicates that they do not have, nor do they want to have, such an account.

However, this wish has no effect on Facebook, they will continue to send him invites on the behalf of his friends, who uploaded his email address for him.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by patrickaljord on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @02:56PM (#1891585)
> Which is precisely Facebook's reasoning for not providing an API to download your friends' email addresses.

So why does it give it to Yahoo mail and Hotmail? Please answer that question.

Relevant link: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1889378

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by quadhome on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @05:00PM (#1891948)
They also give it to me too. I have a Samsung Galaxy S and it, out of the box, syncs with Facebook including e-mail addresses.
Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by jfager on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @02:46PM (#1891552)
What is Facebook's reasoning, then, for providing an API to download complete friend lists, location, real names, and other data a user didn't wade through privacy settings to lock down?

Handing information to a company with which a user never wanted to have a relationship is bad when it results in spam-filled inboxes, which end users might notice and directly associate with FB's policies. As long as the potential abuse is hidden from the user's view, though, FB wholeheartedly endorses it.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by rodericksilva on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:02PM (#1892838)
Ummm...they are my contacts.

"Facebook's reasoning for not providing an API" is because they want to protect me from other Facebook type companies? Really?

...or is it that they don't want us moving our data to another social network?

Let's get real. Facebook can spin it however they want. We all know what's up!

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by confuzatron on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:51AM (#1890939)
...not to mention, a concrete reminder of the hypocrisy of Facebook's argument.

"Facebook - we protect your contacts, so unscrupulous websites can't spam them like we do."

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by GrandMasterBirt on Thursday November 11, 2010 @12:23AM (#1892983)
1000% eh? So you hire 9 slaves to approve alongside you? Interesting. Are they on your contacts? Hmmmm?

Much much much more wiery when people give out their email password to any other service period. Plus why would you care if you can't get the info out of facebook? You already have it in gmail. I dunno, I feel like I dodged so many bullets by not using facebook.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by jasonkester on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:27AM (#1890828)
Actually, it is like they stop you from exporting. Here's the message I get when I try to import my contacts into Faceboook:

Google did not return any of your contacts. You can still find your friends on Facebook by uploading a file of your Gmail contacts below.

... followed by instructions on how to download my gmail contacts to a file and re-upload them.

So it seems that Google's implementation of their "whining at you about their problems while you're just trying to get on with your life" page is broken.

The end result is that you cannot export your contacts from Gmail at the present.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by abrahamsen on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:45AM (#1890907)
Clicking on the link to the "trap" page and checking "Proceed with exporting this data" brings up a "Download my contact information" button. Clicking that gives me a csv file with all my Google contact information.

So I can certainly export my Google contact data. I don't have a Facebook account, so I don't know whether it can import it. But the data is there, in an easy to parse format.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by dedward on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:37AM (#1890874)
You can export them just fine - they just aren't allowing a 3rd party site to automatically import them - they're making you consciously do it yourself.

To someone who can do it either way, this may just seem like an annoyance, but a great many people won't grasp the severity of what they are about to do by handing their credentials for gmail over to facebook.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by jasonkester on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:47AM (#1890924)
Exactly. One week ago, you could seamlessly import them into Facebook.

  - That's a big step back.
  - It makes things worse for their users.
  - There is no positive effect from the change.
  - They did it on purpose.
We're all here because we build web apps for a living. And none of us would ever consider doing something like that with one of our own sites. I have no idea why anybody at Google thought that this was a good idea.
Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by davorak on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @12:48PM (#1891167)
Facebook is play a greedy game theory strategy by not allowing for a user to download their social graph. Googles response was to use a tit for tat game theory strategy which is effective against the greedy game theory strategy.

The greedy game theory strategy in this case ends up being bad for consumers, they can not download their social graph from Facebook. Game theory subjects that when the vast major of agents are using the greedy strategy that is is impractical for a generous or tit for tact agent to survive. Each company that plays the greedy strategy is a step down the road to the greedy equilibrium. Where no companies offer easy methods to download your social graph or relevant information.

Google played a tit for tat strategy and did the world a service by preventing one step on the road to the greedy equilibrium.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by chrischen on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @01:35PM (#1891347)
> Facebook is play a greedy game theory strategy by not allowing for a user to download their social graph.

You CAN download your graph data. You can get friends lists with UIDs, and that is theoretically AND practically enough to reconstruct the graph on a third party site. The only difference between getting UIDs and emails is the third party site won't be able to spam all your friends or connect you with your friends unless you've also opted to use Facebook graph data.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by davorak on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @04:59PM (#1891943)
* If avoiding third party spammers is the reason not to share email address, then it follows that Google should disallow the contacts api. This would be unfortunate

* Google could provide google UIDs instead of emails when downloading contacts. This is theoretically and practically enough to reconstruct the social graph as well. Every company could use their own UID for downloads instead of emails. I do not think it would be practical to reconstruct a social graph across companies however. This is a greedy strategy that would cause inefficiencies and prevent innovation in my opinion.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by chrischen on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @07:42PM (#1892377)
> * If avoiding third party spammers is the reason not to share email address, then it follows that Google should disallow the contacts api. This would be unfortunate

No that doesn't follow because on Google Contacts I give you my email address. On Facebook I "friend" you, which doesn't really even necessarily mean I'm your friend. I don't want you then to be able to automatically export my email to third parties.

> * Google could provide google UIDs instead of emails when downloading contacts. This is theoretically and practically enough to reconstruct the social graph as well. Every company could use their own UID for downloads instead of emails. I do not think it would be practical to reconstruct a social graph across companies however. This is a greedy strategy that would cause inefficiencies and prevent innovation in my opinion.

Google Contacts is for storing emails you've collected. Facebook is for friending people and I just happened to have to provide my email when signing up... oh just like about every other site on the web.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by davorak on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @08:30PM (#1892496)
> No that doesn't follow because on Google Contacts I give you my email address. On Facebook I "friend" you, which doesn't really even necessarily mean I'm your friend. I don't want you then to be able to automatically export my email to third parties.

You can make your email private in Facebook and you do not have to friend people. I would argue for a downloadable list of contacts/email address whose emails you have access to. Facebook already allows hotmail+yahoo access to the email lists, the individual user can not download it directly.

>Google Contacts is for storing emails you've collected. Facebook is for friending people and I just happened to have to provide my email when signing up... oh just like about every other site on the web.

Add decide to let everyone on your friends list have access to your email address, unless you make it private that is. So I would say Facebook is different in this regard then every other site on the web.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by chrischen on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:04AM (#1893150)
> You can make your email private in Facebook and you do not have to friend people. I would argue for a downloadable list of contacts/email address whose emails you have access to. Facebook already allows hotmail+yahoo access to the email lists, the individual user can not download it directly.

I friend people based on the assumption that they can't export my email to arbitrary third parties (which is true at the moment). If this is no longer true I would delete all my friends, sue facebook, and meet friends in person to socialize. But the other thing you mention is reasonable. But it would have to be opt-in since by default I don't think people would want this. Also since originally signing up this feature was not implied.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by rodericksilva on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @11:11PM (#1892858)
So what if I wanted to use my Facebook contacts to see how many of my Facebook friends were on Buzz or Twitter?

Facebook wants us to use our Gmail username and password to import contacts from those services directly into their network but they don't want us importing our contacts into Twitter?

I don't get how that is not a greedy thing.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by chrischen on Thursday November 11, 2010 @04:37PM (#1895378)
> I don't get how that is not a greedy thing.

Because most of Facebook's users didn't sign up for this. They didn't sign up to necessarily share contact info. They signed up to connect socially. Do you expect twitter to start handing out email addresses of the people that sign up on Twitter.com? No because you sign up on Twitter to share short 140 character messages, not email addresses like you do when you sign up to use Google Contacts.

If a third party application wants your email addresses, you can go give it to them yourself. Otherwise what's the point of Facebook making it dead simple for people to give third party apps your email address? The only reason I can think is that greedy third party apps want to siphon Facebook's built up social graph by using spammy viral emailing techniques as opposed to getting individual users to sign up or add the Facebook application.

Also correct me if I'm wrong, but Facebook does let you compare email hashes. So this allows 3rd party apps/sites to link two users up if they are friends on Facebook.

So in the end yes it is convenient for Facebook to take this stance of not making it easy to export your friends' email addresses but it truly does have a legitimate negative aspect to it. And in the end Facebook still provides the requisite methods to make it easy for people to leave Facebook.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by chrischen on Thursday November 11, 2010 @02:01AM (#1893143)
Well if your friends imported their Facebook data into Buzz or Twitter then it should be possible.
Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by stanleydrew on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @12:37PM (#1891134)
There is a positive effect from the change: more people will be aware of Facebook's practices with respect to their contact data. I think Google is betting that this positive effect outweighs the negative effects.
Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by cwlq on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @12:36PM (#1891132)
Because Gmail can't import Facebook contacts. Google is trying to use it's influence to encourage Facebook to improve it's data portability while still not locking users in.

Seems like a good idea to me.

Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by seabee on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @12:03PM (#1890993)
With respect, none of our own sites have the heft of Google behind it.
Re:Gmail: Trap my contacts now (warning when exporting conta... by handrake on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @01:18PM (#1891291)
But it is true that Facebook doesn't allow exporting user's contact data. So I think Google is making a valid point here. You are still free to do whatever with your own data - unlike Facebook. They are just making sure that you understand the risks in doing so.