Re:Simple bouncing ball puzzle, with $50 prize
by greenlblue on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @04:37AM
(#1889758)
I'm not disagreeing with you. Yes, an infinite series can have a finite sum, no argument there but what I am arguing with is that people are saying the ball stops bouncing after time t = whatever. Everyone is confounding two things here, air time and bouncing. Yes, the air time is finite but the bouncing isn't. So you can't say it stops bouncing after time t = whatever if you calculate t = whatever by assuming infinitely many bounces which is what everyone is doing because they are summing a geometric series where the terms of the series represent the air time of each bounce.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Simple bouncing ball puzzle, with $50 prize
by cperciva on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @04:41AM
(#1889763)
There is a time t such that after time t the height of the ball's bounces is zero.
Personally, I call that "not bouncing".
Re:Simple bouncing ball puzzle, with $50 prize
by greenlblue on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @05:03AM
(#1889799)
Ok, now we are in agreement because my definition of "stops bouncing" was finitely many bounces.
Re:Simple bouncing ball puzzle, with $50 prize
by paulofisch on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @05:59AM
(#1889881)
Bzzt Still wrong.
If you have infinite bounces, and I ask you "Which number bounce in the series happens at exactly time X?", there is a time for X for which you will not be able to give an answer.
This is because there is a limit for the latest time at which bounces happen.
Yes, even with infinite bounces.
Re:Simple bouncing ball puzzle, with $50 prize
by greenlblue on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @06:59AM
(#1889995)
Whatever. I got it sorted out so go bother someone else.