I'm the opposite. If I facebook friended someone, I've most likely met them in person, and hence providing my virtual contact is quite all right. Facebook, in a way, is the place you say things to people you're likely to meet face-to-face.
I'm not friends with Arrington on facebook, and wouldn't ever expect to be, although I'd probably follow him on twitter if any of my twitter-friends retweeted him. Yet, his e-mail is probably public knowledge. My point: it's all relative. To converge on a compatible set for all of these rules is social evolution.
Re:Give Us Our Data, Facebook
by patrickaljord on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @02:40AM
(#1889536)
The problem is that they actually do with yahoo mail and hotmail http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1889234 or read the other posts on this threads.
As I understand it, taking a list of FB contacts and turning them into a mass email list would be a violation of the CAN-SPAM rules - people need to explicitly agree to be added to a mail list.
Re:Give Us Our Data, Facebook
by skinnymuch on Wednesday November 10, 2010 @10:30AM
(#1890576)
this is correct. At the same time, the law doesn't really care about a 4,000 person mailing list, or even a 400,000 person mailing list.
So it's right to export your 4000 contacts from GMail and mass mail them, but it's wrong to do the same with Facebook.
With GMail I can export everything and import it to an E-Mail client of my choosing, with Facebook this is impossible, if I join a new social network I have to do everything manually.
In my case, it would be the last thing to happen before I quit FB entirely and stuff my account with bogus info or close it altogether.