News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by dang on Friday January 11, 2019 @11:08PM (#18889578)
Religious flamewar is not welcome here. We've banned this account.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. The rules are at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by h0mEDw on Saturday January 12, 2019 @05:57AM (#18890685)
Eh, I think I have something interesting to say on this topic. I'm not making a "religious flame war", merely stating that literal and thorough implementations of scriptures cause human suffering. Please see this comment:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18888118

Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by dang on Saturday January 12, 2019 @07:42PM (#18894225)
Not what this site is for.
Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by twblalock on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:15PM (#18887109)
> Saudi Arabia is a very thorough implementation of Islam, and therefore a disgusting country.

You make the assumption that the Saudi version of Islam is the only valid one. It's not.

Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by keldaris on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:24PM (#18887208)
I don't think the parent made that assumption, though. They stated it was "thorough", not valid. While I have no idea what a "valid" interpretation of Islam means (it seems like an unprovable honorific, bestowed arbitrarily), "thorough" seems more like an assertion of direct correspondence to the original text.
Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by twblalock on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:44PM (#18887440)
> "thorough" seems more like an assertion of direct correspondence to the original text

Direct correspondence to the original text is not the way most religions work, and it's not the way Christianity and Islam have worked historically.

Scripture is not always interpreted literally, and the people who insist on a literal interpretation are usually innovators, because it wasn't done that way originally.

The literalists are not more thorough than the others in their understanding of their religion or their dedication to it -- they are just more literal in their reading, and often more simplistic in their beliefs as a result.

Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by keldaris on Friday January 11, 2019 @05:25PM (#18887786)
I don't particularly disagree with you, I was simply making an observation that the original claim of "thoroughness" didn't seem to me to imply any assertion of perceived validity.

Besides that, the perceived validity of religious interpretations is largely in the eye of the beholder and statistically varies with sociocultural context and many other factors. Personally, the farther away from literalism people get on the literalist-modern Unitarian scale, the happier I'd be.

Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by h0mEDw on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:24PM (#18887207)
True, but the only way to make it more sensible is to be less thorough. I.e. not implement certain rules that are stated explicitly in the books. Like modern Christians and Jews that do not kill adulterers, even though Deuteronomy explicitly tells them to do so.
Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by twblalock on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:42PM (#18887416)
The literal interpretation of the scriptures is not the only one, and it's certainly not the one that was prevalent historically. That's true for both Christianity and Islam.

To read scripture literally is not more thorough than to interpret it in some other way.

Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by h0mEDw on Friday January 11, 2019 @06:13PM (#18888118)
Well, by thorough I simply meant not skipping any part. And those horrible parts of scriptures from religions originating from middle east (Judaism, Christianity, Islam) really cannot be sensibly interpreted in any metaphoric way unless by skipping it. A common way to do it is by saying "this is very specific code that was only relevant in societies back then; we're wise to not follow it now". But that's just skipping with extra steps.

Edit: just to make sure it's clear - I'm very happy when such skipping happens. A quote from Captive Mind by Czeslaw Milosz:

> When someone is honestly 55% right, that’s very good and there’s no use wrangling. And if someone is 60% right, it’s wonderful, it’s great luck, and let him thank God. But what’s to be said about 75% right? Wise people say this is suspicious. Well, and what about 100% right? Whoever say he’s 100% right is a fanatic, a thug, and the worst kind of rascal.

> By “an old Jew of Galicia”.

Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by selimthegrim on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:26PM (#18887237)
Protip: Stoning for adultery isn’t in the Quran, despite any grumbling about lost verses you might hear.
Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by didgeoridoo on Friday January 11, 2019 @11:07PM (#18889576)
Yes, it’s one of the rare cases where the religion as actually practiced is MORE brutal than its founding text calls for. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rajm
Re:Saudi Women, Tired of Restraints, Find Ways to Flee by perfmode on Friday January 11, 2019 @04:23PM (#18887200)
Saudi Arabia's issues have more to do with authoritarianism. Authoritarianism can come in vanilla, chocolate, or strawberry.