when 6 more months could have fixed it.
Only if you have enough cash to pay everybody for 6 more month.
Yes but if they reduced the feature set and focussed on getting those right (maybe even producing a different game for 1.0) then they wouldn't have a bad game, they'd just have a different game.
"A delayed game is eventually good, a bad game is bad forever." -Shigeru Miyamoto http://www.iwise.com/PW9YU
That said, this attitude is coming from an era when it was difficult to update games after release, so I'm not sure to what extent it still applies.