News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to get your money’s worth from your startup lawyer by gumby on Friday January 11, 2019 @12:49AM (#18881295)
A few points:

- The partner matters a lot more than the firm. For example I used Cooley, but really it was one attorney I wanted. When he moved to another firm my company went with him.

- Of course it's the associates, not the partner who will do 99% of the work -- but that's all you need anyway. The partner however supervises. Ideally you never get a bill for the partner's time.

- In almost any case you should hardly use your lawyers at all in the first year or two. You get standard NDAs (one way and/or mutual) and can fill them in yourself. If you get one from a partner, ask to use yours or read theirs and if it looks really close just use it (unless its some massive one from, say, Intel -- but really, are you going to be able to negotiate that?). Likewise just use standard job offers and confidentiality/assignment forms. No need to pay a lawyer for those once get up. But don't wing it with anything security or debt related!

- Another reason not to care about the firm: a big firm will have lots of services but will you need them? For example for patent filing you may want a boutique firm that specializes in just your area. For HR lawsuits I'd use MoFo even if I don't use them for corporate law.

- Make sure your firm understands startups (this expands on what the article said about "Hire lawyers who have experience with the particular task you are asking them to perform"). Various big firms have opened offices in the Valley in order to get that sweet deal flow. But unless they staff up with some local attorneys with local connections and experience you're not going to get a lawyer who can help you no matter how good they are. Even the startup scenes in NY and Boston are different from each other and from the Valley or SF. Not just network but how people do things.

- an exception to the "firm doesn't matter" rule: Wilson -- not only have I only had bad lawyer experiences (mainly huge Billings) when I was involved with a company that used Wilson, but the only firm that ever asked me to do something illegal (they were representing our investor...but only for that transaction as our lawyer was also the investor's lawyer. For subsequent rounds the investor used someone else, as they were also disgusted with Wilson). There's a reason this onetime "star startup law firm" has been shrinking.

Re:How to get your money’s worth from your startup lawyer by ABCLAW on Friday January 11, 2019 @11:54AM (#18884792)
Select for good people, select against bad firms.

I think you've articulated something key; You need a competent partner to make sure you're getting decent value, regardless of the firm you're at, but firm culture itself can make any practitioner play poorly. This just pulled together a few strings of thought I've had (I have my own internal industry 'bad firm' and 'bad practice group' list in my head), so thanks for this post.