I see (and agree with) your point about worse non-numeric stuff, but if you stand back and squint I get the impression Julia does most of what you applaud here, with the added benefits of a more transparent compiler and a more numeric-focused community (no need for BasicMath there!).
In particular, Flux.jl seems like a fairly direct competitor of S4TF, and this blogpost [0] really blew me away.
[0] https://www.julialang.org/blog/2018/12/ml-language-compiler
Julia is much more mature for machine learning than Swift at this point. So it would be a better choice if you want something that's at least somewhat ready for use now - but I was really wanting to get in on the ground floor on something that's just getting started.
The bigger issue is that to overload a function in a manner similar to C++ you need to have accurate type information, which historically was not available in Objective C since it relies heavily on duck typing and casting objects back through id. If such strong type information was available then the type data could have simply been mangled into the selector by the compiler the same way it is mangled into the symbol name in C++. I suspect that duck typing allowed a lot of productivity and memory wins in the 90s, and that most compilers of the era were not capable of exploiting the strong typing information to optimize as aggressively as they do now, meaning that it was probably the right trade off for the time.
I suppose an alternative implementation of overloading could have been implemented by having objc_msgSend dynamically query the types of all parameters which are overloaded, but that would have resulted in a huge performance hit on every dynamic message dispatch.
You've gotten into a place with a lot of unidiomatic designs--direct pointer access on COW types, etc.--and it's not clear how much is really necessary:
extension Array where Element:CanDoMath {
// instead of this style:
func sum_outside() -> Element {
var result = 0
let p = self.pointerToStorage // your "get the pointer" method, I think it was just `p`, too?
for i in 0..<count {
result += p[i]
}
return result
}
// how does this compare (in -unchecked mode, at least)?
func sum_inside() -> Element {
return self.withUnsafeBufferPointer() {
var result = 0
for v in $0 {
result += v
}
return result
}
}
}
Going the `sum_inside` route for bulk operations makes it easier to remain idiomatic, keep COW around (assuming you want it), benefit from `var/let`, and so on. The only obvious concerns are (a) relative overhead--did you ever benchmark that?--and (b) alignment.For (b) if you're planning to call things that need particular alignments then as far as I know you will need to write your own storage at this time.
Thus we hadn't even considered just exposing the pointer and doing it C-style, whence the question as to whether you'd benchmarked the difference between the two.
The abstractions thing is hard, here, the key seems to be defining the bulk operations in terms of pointers (or Swift's "buffer pointers"), essentially what you have in your methods like `SupportsBasicMath.add` and so on. Abstraction is possible here by moving each "type signature"--destination & 1 source? destination & 2 sources? etc.--into "operation protocols", and then having fewer methods but a ton of "operation protocol implementations". Perhaps "more abstraction", definitely not concise. Very dependent on the compiler and inlining, too.
It's a good writeup nonetheless, was just asking a narrow question.
Because I couldn't find anything that provides that using the approach you are discussing, I didn't investigate its performance characteristics. For me, dev UX comes first, and I wouldn't personally be interested in reading or writing in a language that requires the "with" construct wrapping every calculation.