News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by busterarm on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:32PM (#18875840)
"achievement"

So encouraging men to achieve success in life is harmful?

Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by orestes910 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:34PM (#18875870)
I also liked how "risk taking" was in the toxic group, while "courage" was seen as a positive. Right alongside "leadership".

So, be courageous and lead, but don't do things that require courage or put you in a position of leadership.

Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by 762236 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:38PM (#18875933)
They're saying that men end up constraining themselves. Men could achieve a lot more without the constraints of masculine social mores.
Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by smsm42 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:00PM (#18876188)
Like what? Let's say men are now compelled by social mores to be (more) aggressive risk takers, drive themselves to compete, achieve more and take leadership positions. Leaving aside how incredibly wrong such generalization is, let's assume it's exactly correct. And let's consider a hypothetical where men aren't compelled to do any of that - what would allow such men to "achieve a lot more" while avoiding taking risks, rejecting stoic values of perseverance and hard work, despising leadership and drive to succeed (whatever their definition of success would be), what would be the mechanism of it?
Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by lithos on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:42PM (#18875973)
36 page paper, summarized and simplified to be printed in something mass market. It's pretty clear that what's listed are meant as a combination of things, even in the summary.
Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by rfugger on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:39PM (#18875945)
It can be, certainly. But not always, and quite possibly not even usually, depending on what is meant by "achievement". Failing to encourage achievement can also be harmful. The problem here is that one-word summaries of detailed positions aren't useful, and only lead to semantic arguments.
Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by z_open on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:34PM (#18875875)
I have a hard time with people who believe everything in life is a competition. At work, they have to get ahead. At home, they still have to get ahead. When they eat breakfast, they have to do it better than you. We need to teach people to work towards society's ends, rather than their own.
Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by dekken_ on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:35PM (#18875888)
That would be a "pathological" form of competitiveness
Re:'Traditional masculinity' labeled 'harmful' by the Americ... by axaxs on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:38PM (#18875924)
I do too. But what I've noticed is that those types of people tend to get ahead in their careers at most companies I've been at. And with some companies -still- doing stack ranking, I guess that behavior is encouraged.