The salient point is that people here have rose tinted glasses when it comes to the negative effects of American military actions since the Spanish–American War. For the vast majority of the world, America, China, two sides of the same coin. Just another foreign government telling them what to do and taking things from them under the veneer of helping them.
Russia has reasons to not like the US, but that doesn't mean they will like China more - that is one reason they are neutral. I could make a case that Russia would prefer the US to China - but it is just an argument, only history will tell how changing world affected Russia. Even history cannot tell us how things would be different in some alternative history.
That ain't exactly helping your case.
"Just another foreign government telling them what to do and taking things from them under the veneer of helping them."
Right, but one of them is literally a totalitarian dictatorship, and the other is the United States. The US is by every measure the lesser of the two evils.
My case is amoral. Your dislike of that does not change whether or not my statement is true.
"Right, but one of them is literally a totalitarian dictatorship, and the other is the United States. The US is by every measure the lesser of the two evils."
You do realize that there other cultures view us in the exact same fervent manner right?
Regardless, you don’t have to convince me as much as people living in those countries that the US is working in their interests. And the optics aren’t good right now.
America's dirty laundry is more visible than China's; doesn't mean it's actually dirtier.
You're entitled to remain ignorant, but that entitlement does not equal correctness or sanity.
Ah yes, the classic "America is still doing plenty of bad things today but I'll ignore that so that I can pretend we stopped doing it so that I can continue to pretend that China is the only one doing these things today" argument.
Or is it the "My argument was < the United States - a representative democracy - is equivalent to or worse than China - (again) a totalitarian dictatorship > so I'll start arguing about how our sins are in the past (even though we never made up for most of them) because that proves that we're better since we're a representative democracy" argument.
Can't tell, people make all kinds of funny logical fallacies.
Like, I agree America ain't perfect, but last I checked it ain't systematically and officially imprisoning/torturing/enslaving religious minorities, either (as just one example of the sorts of severe human rights violations China is actively committing at this very moment), nor is it actively preventing its citizens from discussing its very-checkered past (let alone present).
The "hey America does bad things so please don't mind us while we oppress those Tibetans over there" tactic is nothing new, and has been a staple of Chinese apologists for decades, and it falls apart pretty quickly once you scratch through the surface.
Even if we do want to go head-to-head on historical wrongs, the Great Leap Forward alone makes even pre-Civil-Rights-Movement America look utopian in comparison. I guess that's par for the course for these African countries looking for a role model, though: "if China can get away with starving its own people to death while its ruling class eats plentifully and gets richer, then I guess we can, too".
You are ostensibly correct that China treats its own citizens worse than America does in the present day. That is irrelevant to how other countries view the US and China. What matters is how the US and China have treated other countries. On that score, China is far better. The US has been meddling in many countries' internal affairs, launching coups, secretly backing internal groups looking to topple governments. The CIA has been very, very active since its inception. Blowback is a very real thing. The US is simply addicted to foreign military action. We accuse Russia of meddling in our elections when we do the same thing to other countries. Sure, China might decide to do the exact same things, but so far, there hasn't been any evidence that it has, at least not on the same scale. Hence, it's very clear why the places that we have fucked over would view China more positively than the US. They simply don't have the record that we do when it comes to foreign intervention.
http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2014/07/15/which-countr...
My point is simple. The comment I replied to said:
> The salient point is that china as super power is negative independent of where you're sitting.
This is simply not true. There are places that either are not affected and would be neutral, or places that have already been negatively impacted by the US as a superpower and would be positively impacted by having another competing superpower. You then turned this into a game of who has better humans rights and which is the lesser of two evils (which actually is not objective and depends on the viewer) which is a gigantic straw man.
> Even if we do want to go head-to-head on historical wrongs, the Great Leap Forward alone makes even pre-Civil-Rights-Movement America look utopian in comparison.
You wildly underestimate the brutality of slavery era America. Even China doesn't torture its own citizens like how Americans systemically tortured, beat, raped, and generally treated slaves as animals.
China doesn't have citizens roving around committing lynchings and massacres of minorities. They get rounded up but they aren't killed with impunity by the civilians in the majority. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lynching_in_the_United_States. These murderers were often put on trial and found not guilty. That's legally sanctioned murder. The documented incidents are just those that didn't get covered up. Who knows how many other incidents like that happened during the lynching era?
After the Civil War and up until the Civil Rights era, there was a culture of shut your mouth and stay in your lane or you might just end up being killed by a mob of white people that thought you were just a little bit too uppity. Sure it wasn't everywhere, but it was in enough places.
Mass famine makes this look like utopia? On the one hand the famines may have been politically targeted. On the other hand, they didn't actually kill anyone directly compared slavery/lynching. If you wanna call that utopia, fine, you're entitled to your own opinion.
Huh? The Russians got control over half of Europe because they were among the major parties that defeated the Germans in WWII.
Meanwhile, both of the other things happened during a war in which the United States was the defender, not the attacker. They were ultimately in self-defense. There were probably ways of winning WWII that didn't involve quite as many civilian casualties, but hindsight is 20/20, and it ain't like either country the US bombed at that time was in the slightest bit innocent.
Besides, at least in the case of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, there's reason to believe the lives lost on both sides would've been significantly higher had the US not used nuclear weapons. The atom bombs were ultimately a bluff, the goal being to convince the Emperor of Japan to surrender early (by leading him to believe that America was equipped to wipe Japan off the face of the Earth in an instant) instead of continuing to convince his country to fight to the death. Had that bluff failed - or had the US not had a nuclear option - the Pacific Theater would've continued to be a bloodbath.
It was a decision that cost a lot of civilian lives, but the alternatives were worse.
I am far from a defender of China (I'm a rabid capitalist). However, it annoys me to see the US brought up as the lesser of two evils, given that in reality they (like every other government) do whatever they can get away with. (Also, they bombed Japan because they could - and they bombed it twice because they had two different designs and wanted to compare them. It had nothing to do with saving more people in an alleged future.)
They bombed it twice because they had two bombs. If they only wanted to "compare them", they could've dropped them in Nevada like they did previously and subsequently.
And they bombed Japan because they needed to, or at least felt like they needed to given the circumstances of defending themselves against an imperialist threat to all of the Pacific - including, by the way, China.
What a load of crap. That exact same reasoning can be applied to everything the government of China does. They did X because they needed to or they felt they needed to.
That has nothing to do with the morality of it as you keep trying to bring up. So what is it? The ends justify the means or not? You don't get to apply different standards, utilitarian to the US and deontological to China. Scratch that, no you can, it'll just reveal the bias that you have.
Like, you do know about World War II, right? How Japan bombed Pearl Harbor? How Japan invaded China and murdered/raped its people? How Japan threatened and attempted to do the same to the rest of the Pacific, including the US? Four years of bloody non-stop full-scale war led up to the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombings. Those bombings were not done lightly.
It was a regrettable but necessary decision. China's past and present atrocities do not carry anywhere near that degree of necessity.
Who being the aggressor is irrelevant in the moral calculation of whether or not to use nukes. Defeat was inevitable for Japan.
"Like, you do know about World War II, right? How Japan bombed Pearl Harbor? How Japan invaded China and murdered/raped its people?"
Those considerations only matter if you care about revenge when it comes to a foe that can no longer do those things. That can't be what you're advocating for now can it?
Wanting to end the war as quickly as possible is not a morally justifiable reason to use nukes. Waiting out Japan was an absolutely viable option. The recommendations for using the nukes included seeing how they would work in a real use case, not wasting the money put into the Manhattan Project, as well as intimidating the Soviet Union. It was also partly influenced by the Soviets entering the war against Japan
"It was a regrettable but necessary decision. China's past and present atrocities do not carry anywhere near that degree of necessity."
This is a myth bordering on propaganda to justify the usage of nukes.
https://www.ihr.org/jhr/v16/v16n3p-4_Weber.html
Quote: General Douglas MacArthur, Commander of US Army forces in the Pacific, stated on numerous occasions before his death that the atomic bomb was completely unnecessary from a military point of view: "My staff was unanimous in believing that Japan was on the point of collapse and surrender."
General Curtis LeMay, who had pioneered precision bombing of Germany and Japan (and who later headed the Strategic Air Command and served as Air Force chief of staff), put it most succinctly: "The atomic bomb had nothing to do with the end of the war."
Should you not compare 1949 China and Mao with 1940's USA and then compare 2019 US to 2019 China?
The other one is the USA.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_leap_forward
[1] https://www.pri.org/stories/2014-07-14/why-china-fears-falun...
[2] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/05/world/asia/china-xinjiang...
[3] https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2018/jun/6/chinas-chris...
Downvoting this post does not making it less true either.
"Frank Dikötter estimates that at least 2.5 million people [who died as a result of the Great Leap Forward] were beaten or tortured to death and one million to three million committed suicide."
And regarding the famine:
"Yang Jisheng, a long-time communist party member and a reporter for the official Chinese news agency Xinhua, puts the blame squarely on Maoist policies and the political system of totalitarianism,[36] such as diverting agricultural workers to steel production instead of growing crops, and exporting grain at the same time.[82][83] During the course of his research, Yang uncovered that some 22 million tons of grain was held in public granaries at the height of the famine, reports of the starvation went up the bureaucracy only to be ignored by top officials, and the authorities ordered that statistics be destroyed in regions where population decline became evident.[84] "
(EDIT: even better: "Benjamin Valentino writes that like in the USSR during the famine of 1932–33, peasants were confined to their starving villages by a system of household registration,[95] and the worst effects of the famine were directed against enemies of the regime.[31] Those labeled as "black elements" (religious leaders, rightists, rich peasants, etc.) in any previous campaign were given the lowest priority in the allocation of food, and therefore died in the greatest numbers.[31] According to genocide scholar Adam Jones, "no group suffered more than the Tibetans", with perhaps one in five dying from 1959 to 1962.[96]")
Your posts are likely being downvoted because they're misleading to the point of intellectual dishonesty.
Yes that would indicate that the worst effects determined politically. That doesn't mean Mao created a famine, the thing that killed tens of millions of people, to punish those citizens that had the wrong politics and ideas like the claim said
> One of them killed tens of millions (!) of their own citizens for having the wrong politics and ideas[0]
For all your moralizing and posturing, you're have been amazing deceitful in your intellectual dishonesty. Stop bringing up points that distort the actual points being argued as if I can't tell that's what you're doing.
The cited sources literally state that Mao's regime was fully capable of feeding its own people and chose not to because grain exports were deemed a higher priority.
Are you refuting that? If so, then on what grounds? If not, then the claim that "Mao created a famine" and "the famine disproportionately targeted enemies of Mao's regime" are somehow entirely disconnected is an amazing feat of mental gymnastics.
> you're have been amazing deceitful in your intellectual dishonesty
Hello there, Pot. Nice to meet you! I'm Kettle.
> Stop bringing up points that distort the actual points being argued as if I can't tell that's what you're doing.
TIL presenting facts is "distort[ing] the actual points being argued".
Ah well, looks like I learned something new today.
"TIL presenting facts is "distort[ing] the actual points being argued". "
Nah, it's your use of strawman arguments.