News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who are the polite Indians? by FraaJad on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @09:34AM (#1886513)
Most "CS" students in India don't go to engineering schools because they like it. They take up CS because that's the most lucrative career option right now.

The competition is cut throat to get into major IT companies (GPA of 3.75 or higher is required by most "Grade A" companies just to take the preliminary written tests.)

Unfortunately, most of the companies value grades and how "consistent" you have been through school, going all the way back to 10th grade. (I'm looking at you Infosys. I should write up my own interview experience with them :)

As long as they get their grades, the students are least bothered about how they got it.

Given this pressure, one can hardly expect 18-21 year olds to be cognizant of how rest of the world perceives them. What matters to them is their social circle and family priorities. If it means asking 100 people to bump up the grade, so be it.

Re:Who are the polite Indians? by aniket_ray on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @10:02AM (#1886610)
I think a lot of what you say is the correct. I'll just add to that.

Most of these "polite Indians" are college students from not-so good colleges (or bad students at good colleges). They are studying Engineering just because of parental/peer pressure. I'm sure every Indian would know more than 3-4 friends who are studying just to make somebody else proud.

Each semester, these students have some courses with assignments. The first thing they do is "Google" the assignment. If they don't find the solutions on the front page of Google, they either raid forums (including comment sections of blogs) asking for help or else they contact a small coding shop and "outsource" their assignments. These coding shops are small shops that charge extremely low rates too, so they don't have the best programmers either. Quite often coding shop employees raid the web for help too. A friend of mine has actually hired 3-4 "sub-standard" coders proceeds of which he uses to bootstrap his main startup.

Unfortunately, in this storm sometimes even genuine students who just wish to learn get crowded out. My suggestion (and what I do generally) is to answer people as long as it is just about concepts. If you start doing somebody else's homework the whole batch might start asking you for help. So, my advice is just don't do anybody's homework.

Re:Who are the polite Indians? by jgrahamc on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @10:05AM (#1886624)
I try to help people to help themselves. At some point I have to give up. For example: http://imgur.com/qdV0B.png
Re:Who are the polite Indians? by dpritchett on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @11:26AM (#1886923)
There's an occasionally inappropriate photoshop meme for this phenomenon. "High Expectations Asian Father" plays on the achievement-oriented bootstrappers' world-view often ascribed to first-generation immigrant parents.

http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/high-expectations-asian-father

Re:Who are the polite Indians? by DLaulkar on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @05:48PM (#1888294)
I came across very interesting blog check out

"indian software giants misleading talent in india"

http://www.dkoustubha.com/indian-software-giants-misleading-...