News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by sjg007 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @01:45PM (#18858196)
It will happen if you vote blue. The first wave of it was 10 year of payments and then debt forgiveness.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by xyzzyz on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @01:47PM (#18858216)
That will push college prices even higher.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by kamarg on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @02:07PM (#18858472)
Can you explain why that is to me? I would think that if the expected return on college loans drops significantly, fewer large loans would be given out that can be passed on to universities which would see less demand for their product and would need to lower their prices accordingly.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by Mountain_Skies on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @02:52PM (#18858985)
The universities aren't on the hook for student loan defaults so they don't care about the expected return for the borrower or the lender. If students borrowed from the schools directly, then the admissions process along with university spending patterns would be vastly different. The only thing we have that is remotely close to this is schools giving out scholarships to students who have great potential to be high earners who later donate back to the school.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by l9k on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:52PM (#18860105)
A startup called Lambda started teaching (online) for free in exchange for a percentage of the new graduate's salary. This is called Income Sharing Agreements (ISA).

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/08/business/dealbook/educati...

Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by sjg007 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @02:46PM (#18858924)
There are plenty of mechanisms to counter this. One is direct funding of colleges as we did before via state and Federal funding. Another is to establish a feedback loop where loan guarantees and funding for the institution are a function of their students default rate: that way if the education doesn't lead to jobs then the school gets less money.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by vondur on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:00PM (#18859647)
That will lead to universities only accepting students that would get jobs after graduation, which would probably kill many majors that don’t have high employment rates.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by xyzzyz on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:32PM (#18859911)
Not really; most university graduates can find jobs relatively easily. Unemployment among young diploma-holders in the US is very low, and the diploma premium to income is high, though of course varies by the major. What will rather happen is that less-well-paying majors will become cheaper.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by gowld on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:29PM (#18859878)
Which is... fine?

We don't need millions of people learning unproductive things for excessive prices.

Obvious people who can afford to learn something for fun can do so, and knowledge that is socially valuable but not economically valuable can be supported by government or private patrons who see the social merit. Both are better than duping kids into huge loans.

Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by sjg007 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:11PM (#18859740)
Nah.. right now the risk is born uniformly across all tax payers. We should make the school responsible for some of it.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by Red_Pill_Phil on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @11:48AM (#18866212)
What about those of us who didn't go because we knew we wouldnt be able to pay it off?

Do I get a credit of some sort and how large should that credit be?

I have debts too friend.

Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by porphyrogene on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @01:50PM (#18858274)
> It will happen if you vote blue.

Unfortunately it is a matter of voting blue enough, not just blue. In some areas politicians, even Democrats, regularly relate to their constituents by bashing "East cost liberal elites" despite having degrees from Ivy League schools. If Doug Jones had said that a liberal arts education is valuable for developing into a well-rounded citizen his race would have ended then and there.

Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by StevePerkins on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @02:09PM (#18858493)
I have a college degree. I hope for my kids to take the path of earning college degrees. I think that college is great in the abstract. I also think that until we sort out our health care system in this country (USA), a career in the trades is a very frightening prospect.

Even so, this comment is very interesting to me.

I frequently see on Hacker News the sentiment that modern higher education is a bubble. That if we don't actively encourage young people to consider a life in the skilled trades, we should at least be teaching respect for those who do.

But at the same time, it's hard to ignore the open derision toward non-college grads.

I mean, in this particular example, why SHOULD non-college grads support a politician's promises to subsidize colleges, at the expense of other more direct interests? There are obvious cultural/tribal resentments in play, as you're talking about transferring wealth from one class to another class which openly looks down upon the first. But even separating emotion from it, it's hard to criticize strawmen for opposing policy that might well reasonably be seen as voting against their own interests.

Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by gowld on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:31PM (#18859895)
Subsidized college is for the rural and urban poor, no the elites. Elites don't wait for subsidies, and low-SES people need more cheap vocational/technical colleges to raise their SES.
Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by porphyrogene on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:35PM (#18859948)
I do not have a college degree. I was not speaking about politicians promising to subsidize higher education but I can speak to that anyway. I said that in many parts of the country, even in areas where voters are willing to cast a blue vote, education is viewed as a tool used by the wealthy elite to disqualify the viewpoint of the commoner.

George W. Bush famously spoke of following his "gut" when asked about his decision process concerning foreign policy. In doing so science, research and general means of informed decision-making were dismissed as a way for an elitist to tell laborers that they're too stupid to understand his thought process. The hypocrisy is that he himself went to Yale and Harvard and clearly values higher education; he joined the same secret society at Yale to which his father and grand-father had belonged. This trend has continued to the point that lowly insults are preferred by most voters over policy discussion. This is true of both parties. (e.g. "Pocahontas", "motherfucker")

The reality is that education in and of itself is a societal equalizer. A liberal arts education was developed in the ancient world to equip people with the skills that they needed to live freely as members of a society: logical reasoning, self-expression and the ability to record your thoughts and interpret the thoughts of others. We now speak of education in terms of time commitment and expected pay-off, the massive debt considered an unavoidable nuisance. It is often after a child has selected a college or university that they consider how they will pay (or accrue debt) for it. The elites know that education is a equalizer and that is why they try so hard to frame it as a tool for the enemy of the common people. The last thing that the elites would want is commoners getting wise. When common people do see the value of education they are buried in debt to stifle their upward mobility.

To answer your question, non-college graduates should support the subsidization of higher education because nothing could do more to serve them and their interests. For the time being tough, pursuing an education may mean separating the concept of education from what we have learned to think of as an educational institution. I don't have a college degree and I don't want one (i.e. I don't want to earn one at this time) but I am convinced by the reasoning behind supporting education that has been repeated for thousands of years. In my opinion it is tantamount to supporting the advancement of human civilization and right now we desperately need a renaissance.

Re:A Guide for Adults Going to College by sjg007 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @04:13PM (#18859747)
Eventually that non-college grad will need the services of the college grad (and vice versa) so really it should all come out in the wash right?