News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Blub Paradox (2014) by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @01:11PM (#18857818)
I think it's more that Lisp is really great for certain things. Those certain things aren't all of programming, though. People use Lisp for a problem that's a good fit, and it's like a revelation - programming is insanely fun and productive. So they become a convert, and think that Lisp is The One Right Way To Program.

But in another problem domain, Lisp is terrible. I wouldn't want to program an embedded system with memory-mapped I/O in Lisp. I wouldn't want to do high-performance computing, where I had to get the memory alignment right to get the best performance.

Lisp might be like a Formula 1 racer. If you ever drive one, it will probably revolutionize your idea of what a car can be. Just don't try to drive it on a four-wheel drive road - a Jeep will absolutely dominate it there. For that matter, a Formula 1 car is not even a very good car for commuting to work - not street legal, lousy gas mileage, too high maintenance.

And this is what's wrong with the Blub Paradox idea. Power? Power for what? A language has a certain power for a particular kind of problem, and a different power for a different kind of problem. Pick the language that is the most powerful for your problem, not the language that is "the most powerful".

There are no comments on this comment yet.