News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by gojomo on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @02:21AM (#1885701)
Of course, pictures like this are more profound for what you don’t see: country borders.

There are some borders you can see from space, such as the transition between North and South Korea:

http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/world/dprk/dprk-dark....

Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by nhebb on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @03:25AM (#1885822)
Of course, pictures like this are more profound for what you don’t see: country borders.

I don't know why the author thought that was so profound. Did he really expect the borders to be outlined with lights?

Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by mapleoin on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @05:11AM (#1886004)
I think this paragraph should shed a bit more light on what the author meant:

But if enough people can get to space, they’ll see the planet for what it is: a fragile, magnificent ball with a thin shell of atmosphere protecting it from the entire Universe… and no artificial boundary lines to be seen. We made those ourselves, and we put an awful lot of stock in them. Remembering that fact might also be an important way to make sure our species endures.

Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by three14 on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @05:27AM (#1886024)
I have no problem getting rid of international borders. Just install a global government of my choosing to control everything. No one else will have a problem with my choice, right?
Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by three14 on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @10:28AM (#1886688)
Interesting that this was downvoted - probably because someone was impressed by the importance of remembering that we all need to unite to solve problems. I was trying point out how many problems are solved because we have international borders. Absolute power corrupts absolutely? We at least can limit power at borders. Seeking asylum? Sure is great that there's more than one country. Your government taken over by Communists? At least there are other countries reminding your fellow citizens that Communism isn't the best idea. It's not like you actually need borders to create wars.

Jared Diamond in Guns, Germs, and Steel argues that Western Europe became more advanced than China despite a head start in China because there were so many countries, so one country's government couldn't ruin things.

Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by mkarmac on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @02:16PM (#1887553)
This idea of "containment" may have worked well in the past, but is not as practical anymore. The world is so deeply connected, and technology so advanced, that international cooperation is far more essential.

Nuclear weaponry is but one of a number of salient examples. Even such staunch realists as Kissinger have come to recognize that they must be eliminated, and that intense international cooperation will be necessary to do so:

http://www.hoover.org/publications/hoover-digest/article/610...

Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by three14 on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @03:42PM (#1887832)
I agree with that. (Well, except for the idea that it's practical to get rid of every last nuke.) We need to work together AND we benefit from having separate countries and borders.
Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by mynameishere on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @06:47AM (#1886145)
That "fragile" ball and "thin" atmosphere have been going strong for millions and millions of years. What the heck does he consider "enduring"? Fashionable politics really clouds the brain.
Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by masklinn on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @08:35AM (#1886330)
> What the heck does he consider "enduring"

Our pretty fragile species. As a ball of rock going through the solar system, the earth itself will keep going until the sun blows up, and so will life itself more than likely. But we don't live in the whole planet, the biosphere (and even more so the section of it we can in) is a fragile shell and its destruction will translate in ours.

Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by bendtheblock on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @05:28AM (#1886026)
It's profound because it's a reframing - we lose assumptions by viewing the Earth from Space.
Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by nhebb on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @06:24AM (#1886109)
The author looked at a night photo of one part of the world and made a wispy proclamation on par with a John Lennon song. Nice idea when you're stoned, but he doesn't really expound on the thought to any depth. It's not profound.

One of my favorite shows is The Sons of Anarchy, a modern day take on Hamlet with a motorcycle club as the back drop. The club was established on the principles of anarchist writer Emma Goldman, and it's interesting how they portray the world of anarchy. As a biker gang, they reject the laws of the world at large, but they seek order at a tribal level, with a president and VP of the club. They want to maintain peace in their hometown, but their quests are geared toward survival and prosperity. It's just a TV show, though. It's not profound. But as a microscopic view of what a borderless world might look like, it's a better starting point that a night photo of the Nile.

Re:Turns out, it is a river in Egypt by oiuytgfyhujik on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @09:45AM (#1886552)
There is a whole-earth poster like this and some borders are very obvious.

Rich countries have street lighting, poor countries didn't - even the west-east German border used to be very obvious. 20 years later cheap fluorescent tubes are everywhere which has blurred this a little