News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by lukifer on Monday January 07, 2019 @06:53PM (#18851563)
Yet another reason why Proof of Stake is destined to outcompete Proof of Work. ;)
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by garmaine on Monday January 07, 2019 @07:02PM (#18851626)
Proof of Stake is a perpetual motion machine. You can't safely tie consensus to something (stake) which is determined by consensus. That's circular reasoning and ungrounded.
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by drb91 on Monday January 07, 2019 @11:46PM (#18853226)
What would failure look like?
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by garmaine on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @01:51AM (#18853809)
A system that has effectively bifurcated with conflicting chain tips caused by rewriting history with new nodes unable to tell which is original, or a fully centralized stake-mining where a subset of stake voters game the system to unfairly select themselves out of proportion of their stake weight.
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by koheripbal on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @02:42PM (#18858877)
Is that reeealy so different from a PoW fork?
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by garmaine on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:04PM (#18861400)
A proof-of-work fork is an unstable situation, resolved when more work is applied to one side vs the other, which inevitably happens without active intervention. A proof-of-stake fork is permanent--someone new to the network has no built-in mechanism for deciding which side to prefer: they both seem equally valid.

A properly constructed proof-of-work mechanism has no built-in mechanism for a malicious minority hash power to take control of the protocol, shutting out the higher hash rate majority from mining blocks.

Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by jki275 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @10:42AM (#18856276)
And yet we have multiple Proof of stake coins that seem to work just fine.
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by garmaine on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:07PM (#18861412)
Until they don't. There have been proof-of-stake failures before, and there will be more. Every proof-of-stake system is either (a) known to be broken, or (b) too complicated to analyze to show how it is broken. As the exploitable order depth in category (b) increases, it becomes worthwhile to invest the hours, days, weeks, months it takes to develop attacks against these Rube Goldberg contraptions and they get moved to category (a).
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by jki275 on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:36AM (#18864543)
That's an assertion that I haven't seen any data to back.

I don't believe either (a) or (b) applies to either xtz or to ada, though ada hasn't yet deployed POS.

I can well believe that there are broken POS implementations, there have been a lot of broken implementations of a lot of things in the space -- but claiming every system is known to be broken or cannot be analyzed is a very bold claim to make.

Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by garmaine on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @07:39PM (#18870522)
How would you expect a statement that certain mechanisms have become too complex for review to be backed by data? What observations could I convey to you over a HN comment other than “go look for yourself”?

For a write up of the general, unavoidable problems of proof of stake, see Andrew Poelstra’s proof of stake FAQ.

Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by jki275 on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:08PM (#18870656)
I gave you two of the best known examples of proof of stake that there are. The Tezos team has done it and it's been running for about a year now. The Cardano team is doing it, and I'll link their paper below.

As far as Poelstra, that's a rather old document. A great deal of research has been done in the field since.

Cardano's paper: https://eprint.iacr.org/2016/889.pdf

Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by garmaine on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @11:47PM (#18871597)
No new research can overturn the basic fact that proof of stake claims to do is impossible. It's perpetual motion machine. You can make proof of stake schemes more complicated, but it doesn't gain you actual security, just obscurity. You can't actually achieve the desired outcome of proof-of-work properties for a stake-based consensus mechanism.

What has happened instead is that the basic / easy to analyze systems were broken, and so complications were added that defeated the simple attacks, but really just make attacking it more complicated. But there's no asymmetric advantage against attackers here -- a similarly complex attack can be made for any proof of stake scheme.

Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by jki275 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @07:29AM (#18873360)
If you want to claim it's a perpetual motion machine, you're going to have to prove that claim.

There are a whole lot of very smart people who disagree with you.

Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by garmaine on Thursday January 10, 2019 @09:35AM (#18874068)
The paper by Poelstra has details.
Re:We can confirm that there was a successful 51% attack on ... by jki275 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:40PM (#18877884)
I read it. It's old, and the issues in it have been addressed. There have been several years of research since that paper was released. I've pointed you to an academic paper that addresses the issues.

I'm done with this discussion as you're simply repeating the same things over and over.