News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Hacker News firehose by tptacek on Monday November 08, 2010 @09:45PM (#1885076)
I'm generally disinclined to replace HN's existing RSS with someone else's RSS feed that might at any moment stop working. HN RSS sucks, but I never have to think about it.

As someone else pointed out, I also depend on SearchYC, which is an external application. The difference is the SearchYC is extraordinarily well known. HN can't cut off SearchYC without alienating a sizeable group of site veterans.

That's more than you probably wanted to know, but, hey, you asked.

Re:My Hacker News firehose by PakG1 on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @01:08AM (#1885559)
I think that's an unfair and inconsistent application of logic.

I like reading HN and recently contributing tiny bits to HN because I think the community here is top-notch, friendly, and knows its stuff. HN never struck me as elitist; rather, it's more like a really friendly meritocracy. About the most elitist it gets is requiring a karma threshold to be able to downvote, but that's really just part of being a good meritocracy.

But to be accepting of one add-on application simply because of heavy site veteran patronage, while rejecting all others... THAT would strike me as heavy elitism and not in line with what seems to make HN so great. If add-on apps MUST be rejected, the criteria should be for other more respectable reasons, no? And mind you, it's all pg's call anyway.

Re:My Hacker News firehose by tptacek on Tuesday November 09, 2010 @09:02AM (#1886400)
That would be elitist. If it was what I was saying.