News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by johnnyfaehell on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:08PM (#18850092)
Yea, but the princple remains. He bad mouthed the police so they arrested for it. In a country like the US where it appears that unduly high bails are set. (thousands of dollars for people on welfare may as well be a million) Getting arrested could easily mean the lose of freedom for a extended period of time. If that is the penalty for saying something, true or false. It suddenly becomes something people are afraid to do.
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by qbz on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:11PM (#18850128)
He said an officer is corrupt and that the chief is covering it up. The NYT calls this "disparaging", but it clearly goes way beyond badmouthing.
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by darkpuma on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:18PM (#18850220)
Those are very tame accusations to level against civil servants. They may be totally false, but far worse is regularly stated by people every day. Arresting people for unjustified accusations against the police is obscene, the potential for abuse is way too high.
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by reaperducer on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:16PM (#18850194)
Imagine a world where everyone who accused a public servant of being corrupt, or covering things up was arrested. Every politician would be in jail after each campaign season.
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by coldtea on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:26PM (#18850294)
>Every politician would be in jail after each campaign season

Sounds like a better world!

Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by darkpuma on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:32PM (#18850370)
Every critic of those politicians would be in jail too.
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by coldtea on Monday January 07, 2019 @06:10PM (#18851255)
Why would anybody bother to criticize them if they're going to jail at the end of their campaign anyway (as is the premise in this thread)?
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by darkpuma on Monday January 07, 2019 @06:24PM (#18851355)
Surely you understand that people criticize murderes who are being sent to prison; you don't question why they bother. Why would people stop criticizing a politician simply because they know that politician will be going to jail?

This whole conversation has become very silly. It's plain that criminal libel is an awful idea, we can joke about silly scenarios that might unfold if people facing criminal libel charges were required to prove their innocence, but current criminal libel laws with a normal burden of proof are already being abused and doing real damage to the lives of real people, which isn't very funny.

Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by coldtea on Monday January 07, 2019 @07:34PM (#18851800)
>Why would people stop criticizing a politician simply because they know that politician will be going to jail?

They could, but it would be futile. The politician is not going to govern anybody anyway (remember, straight to jail from the end of their campaign).

Besides, surely you understand that this thread has stretched a BS hypothetical.

Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by darkpuma on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:04PM (#18852428)
> "They could, but it would be futile. The politician is not going to govern anybody anyway (remember, straight to jail from the end of their campaign)."

You've a strange notion of how people behave. People still routinely criticize Bush and Obama, even though neither will ever be in office again. That's how people are.

Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by MrTonyD on Monday January 07, 2019 @04:18PM (#18850214)
I've known a few policemen here in the USA - and every one of them was corrupt. So in this case the law may not make sense.
Re:He Disparaged the Police on Facebook, So They Arrested Him by MrTonyD on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @12:08AM (#18853337)
I share my very real world experience of police in the USA, and I get downvoted for it. I must be posting on Hacker News. (I now consider it a badge of honor to get downvoted. It means those who can't entertain disconfirming thoughts have been offended.)