Re:How innovative is Clojure as a Lisp dialect from Lisp exp...
by kbp on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:30AM
(#18845343)
It's too early to say. Clojure's still very young in Lisp terms, so it's
natural that it has more hype around it now than languages that were cool 30
years ago. It's also not exactly taking over the world, and I think you're
forgetting the buzz Lisp had in the 80s. It will be an innovation in the sense
you mean if it has wide adoption and hype in 2050, but it's certainly not
anything unprecedented yet.
However, if "Clojure" in that sentence is interpreted in a wider, more general and necessarily less concrete sense -- to represent the language, ecosystem, branding, etc -- good marketing/advertising, community management, and general operations-level can be rife with places to innovate.
An excellent language that never gets adopted has effectively zero value IMHO until it's corpse is ransacked by a language that does get adopted. People rediscover things that older languages have done all the while almost every week it seems -- creating a language and the requisite community to actually drive adoption can be considered innovative if the rest of the rest of the landscape is sufficiently similar. Clearly the Clojure project is doing something differently from the Common Lisp/Scheme/Racket crowd.