News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:05PM (#18842449)
Hah! Well let’s do an experiment. I’m going to give what I think is the point of view of your typical right winger and your typical centrist democrat, and then hopefully someone can educate me as to where I’m wrong. To be clear I’m going to go for the basic profile here. Nuance is for cowards.

Conservatives: I was born in 1948. When I was a young adult, everyone was ok and everything made sense. There was an order to things, everyone had a place. Our great enemy was communism; we had capitalism and were free, while our enemies were communists and lived under dictatorship. I was afraid of communism because communists almost blew up the world, plus we fought them in Vietnam. Communists are bad people and therefore their ideas are bad ideas. I suspect that all liberals are either explicitly communist or are being misled by communist appeals to emotionalism. What we need is a strong rational person who will take charge and root out the people who are getting out of place and ruining things for everyone else.

Centrist liberal: I was born in 1972. When I was a young adult, politics were civil and everyone was polite. I never really paid attention to politics because I thought it was boring. I like my job and I think my boss is a great guy. My favorite political figure was Martin Luther king, because he said that everyone should be nice and get along. I’m not racist, because I like Martin Luther king. I don’t understand why everyone seems so angry these days. Technology is so amazing these days, it’s just going faster and faster. I love buying new fancy things. I think that if we could just elect more democrats to congress, then everyone will be nice again and stop being so nasty to each other.

How’s my empathy? Am I close? I would love it if someone would give a similar treatment to the anarchist/socialist point of view, just so I can see what kinds of silly things people believe about me. Turnabout is fair play. Let me have it.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by jeffdavis on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:16PM (#18842495)
I think the main flaw is thinking that there is some "typical" person from each group.

But you are close enough to write a few tertiary characters for an Oscar-winning picture. (Though not a main character; those usually develop throughout the movie and don't fit a static description.)

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by whatshisface on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:48PM (#18842613)
>just so I can see what kinds of silly things people believe about me.

Ok, I'll give it a shot.

Anarchist/Socialist/Anarcho-Capitalist: A lot of my friends support this fringe political position, and they seem cool and well-esteemed within my social circles. Everyone can list a thousand reasons why Republicans or Democrats are corrupt and stupid, and to think of it I don't really know a single person at my university that wholeheartedly supports the platform of either one. I trust the negative things I hear about parties a lot more than the positive things I hear about them, and because the news has never even mentioned the group I consider myself a part of, we're miles ahead of everyone else. To be honest, I don't really see how Democrats or Republicans manage to choose their beliefs, except by imitating each other for social reasons. Any real argument I hear in favor of anything comes across as a rapturous epiphany, because for the first 18 years of my life until now I have only seen other people choosing their beliefs by copying each other for social reasons. I'm so glad that I managed to break free from that system; I'm having a great time visiting the local anarchist bookstore for their special events, and I'm going steady with a girl/guy I met there. My newfound relationships really motivate me to keep up with the literature.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:56PM (#18842653)
Love it! A few things wrong though: I was introduced to socialism in my 30’s after thinking socialist type thoughts for years and believing I was all alone. I’m married and my wife is not so far to the left as me; but we’ve both moved farther left after we got hitched. I do have lots of friends who think more or less this way. I understand that capitalism also has things it does well, and worry about how socialism can replicate those successes (and if it should even try).
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by jeffdavis on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:26PM (#18842540)
A bit off topic, but I am confused how anarchism and socialism can work together. Can you explain?
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:41PM (#18842589)
Socialism is a broad term that includes two main branches; state communism, which emphasizes a planned economy, and anarchism, which emphasizes fighting any kind of heirarchy including state power. In an anarchist world all decisions would be made on the local level wherever possible and businesses would be run democratically by their workers.

Anarchists see anarchism as the skill of organizing and working without having people simply follow orders, which if you think about your private life you probably do it all the time. But at work you do what you’re told, which is in our view a gross assault on your personal integrity.

In the anarchist view if there is a large power differential between two people there is simply no way for them to deal fairly with one another. A legal system is just a band-aid. Hoping for nicer rulers is delusional. The solution is that nobody should have that kind of power in the first place. This extends to male power over women and white supremacy as well.

But it’s still considered a branch of socialism, associated with the writings of Bakunin and Kropotkin.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Monday January 07, 2019 @07:02AM (#18844510)
Hey I’m kind of perplexed, everything I wrote in the parent comment is factual information about what anarchists believe, why the downvotes? If you don’t believe me you can look it up:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchism

Downvoting facts just because you don’t like them says more about you than about me, does it not?

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by james_s_tayler on Monday January 07, 2019 @05:43AM (#18844206)
How effective do you really think a democratically run business could be?

Such companies would be very limited in size and capacity to produce output.

If you had a hypothetical Anarchist country with an Anarchist economy where all the companies were run this way, they would all be outcompeted by the capatilist companies of other nations and the local economy would collapse.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Monday January 07, 2019 @06:55AM (#18844482)
Well that’s just flat wrong. Here’s an example of an association of worker collectives in Spain known as the Mondragon Corporation which employs 75000 people:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation

I mean in the age of feudalism I’m sure people thought the idea of electing their kings would have sounded equally bizarre.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by james_s_tayler on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:46PM (#18860528)
Well that's an interesting data point. Ray Dalio's Principles is another interesting data point on an alternative way to run an organization. These seem to me variations on a similar theme though.

They don't at all make the case for anarchy. The hierarchies are still there and still necessary.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by mebassett on Monday January 07, 2019 @07:11AM (#18844563)
I think you are both touching on the question of "if capitalism is so great, why do firms exist?". You might find the work of Ronald Coase interesting in that regard (see https://www.economist.com/leaders/2013/09/07/the-man-who-sho...). The basic idea is that transaction costs for smaller decisions become too high, so it makes sense to have a figure with authority to make certain transaction decisions by fiat. I think Mondragon still has such authority figures, but it has a more "humanist" corporate structure, composed of co-ops, rather than the shareholder-directors-mgmt-and-workers structure in an american c-corp.

corporate structures do matter.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by james_s_tayler on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @06:08PM (#18860685)
Pretty much. Essentially if you run a thought experiment through several permutations you can roughly compute that this is the case. I always find blowing things up to extremes usually makes certain things come into focus quite well. For example if the organisation has 100,000 people across a multiple geographic regions and then it is discovered that one of the bathrooms have run out of toilet paper, it's not really feasible to call a company all hands meeting to decide who should buy some more toilet paper, where they should buy it from, which brand it should be. If everyone is involved in every decision that pushes productivity to absolute zero the larger the firm grows, though it possibly works for extremely small cases.

By the same token flip the lever hard in the other direction. Imagine management never trusts any expert or IC to ever take a decision on their own. Things get produced but quality plunges abysmally.

There are many configurations things can be in, but from some basic thought experiments you can work out that there is likely a certain operational envelope with a handful of parameters that produce stable, workable results inside the operational envelope and either unstable or unworkable results outside of it.

Some other thought experiments you can try are imagine a world in which no one is trustworthy. Well, it's close to impossible to do business because you have to spend so long figuring out who to do business with that you can't do business with anyone. Imagine a world where nobody ever cheats you and always presents an accurate, trustworthy description of what transaction will take place. Business flies along because you can do away with a lot of overhead that goes in to accounting for that stuff. So it seems trust is an important parameter. Firms make sense from the perspective of having people available (you can trust you have resources to meet demand) and who you trust to be able to complete the work. If you have to go to market every time you can't necessarily guarantee the company you are doing business with will stay in business or keep you as a client or any number of things. So there's a trade-off being made there and there are certain inflection points where on choice stops making sense and another one starts.

Just thinking about it now it seems that the parameters include, but at not necessarily limited to:

  communication bandwidth/overhead
  trust
  alignment of incentives
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by claudiawerner on Monday January 07, 2019 @05:53AM (#18844253)
Which is why no anarchist (and anarchism necessitates the removal of the state) argues for "anarchism in one country", not only because it's oxymoronic but because it's unworkable for the reasons you mentioned and more.
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by jeffdavis on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:59PM (#18842663)
Interesting. It still sounds like you'd need some kind of big state around to constantly hammer down these power dofferentials. And it's not clear how something like that would work in a globalist world. But thank you for a sincere answer.

I do have some overlapping views. Basically I think most cities/communities should be run with center-left-democratic policies, the federal government should be run as libertarian, and states would vary between what we now call Democrats and Republicans. In other words, the nature of government should change depending on the scale. What would I call that viewpoint?

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Sunday January 06, 2019 @11:23PM (#18842755)
Libertarian, I suppose. I was libertarian until I got my first corporate job, when I realized that every large corporation internally functions just like a Stalinist state. I mean Brezhnev had nothing on corporate America when it comes to bureaucracy..
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by burfog on Monday January 07, 2019 @12:37AM (#18843033)
Ah, well, the nice thing about the current system in the USA is that nobody will stop you from forming a commune. If things were flipped around, with the government being socialist, you couldn't escape that.

No, it isn't perfect. In either case there would be a national government demanding taxes and conscription and not assaulting people, but in your case this is a very minor issue because you're wanting the more-shared option.

Good luck.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by claudiawerner on Monday January 07, 2019 @05:56AM (#18844263)
>If things were flipped around, with the government being socialist, you couldn't escape that.

I'm curious as to why.

>but in your case this is a very minor issue

I don't think that's true; the state still has power over you and the power to compel you to pay money and live by its (potentially and actually unjust) laws. That's fundamentally opposed to anarchists' goals. The goals of the anarchists aren't only immediately practical (communal production) but long-term practical as well. If one's goal is to eliminate unjust hierarchy (just as the liberal democrat's goal is to eliminate rights violations) then it won't do to live in a few communes here and there. There must be reform of the whole system.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by whatshisface on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:28PM (#18842548)
Well, first you figure out which genes code for self-interested behavior...
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:44PM (#18842600)
Huh?
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by whatshisface on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:57PM (#18842658)
State communism is diametrically opposed to anarchist personal freedom, because what are you going to do about the defectors that use their personal freedom to start trading? You have to be able to turn off the "personal freedom" switch once someone starts doing something that, if left unchecked, would switch society to a different form of government. The joke is that if you're not going to do it with police (which would be authoritarian), then you'd have to make it so that the idea "why don't we exchange goods and services," and the idea "why don't we band together to get one up on every other race," and the idea "why don't we start bashing unpopular people's heads in to steal their corn," never even enters into the minds of people who want to climb up higher than everyone else.
Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Sunday January 06, 2019 @11:21PM (#18842749)
Exchanging things for things is fine under anarchism. Exchanging your freedom for money would be bad. The question: how do you keep it from happening without a big nasty authoritarian state? Is a valid one.

In my view there would be 3 safeguards: 1) it would be seen as morally repugnant, like banging your cousin. 2) the other, democratic businesses in the area would just refuse to do business with you 3) in the absence of material want, nobody would feel compelled to sell their labor the way they do now, where they have no real choice. The first thing that happened when England went capitalist in (I think) the 1700’s is that the land that used to be held in common was privatized and people were displaced to the cities, where they had to find jobs. In other words the state deliberately created a situation where people had no choice but to sell their time for money.

In the case of someone accumulating actual weapons and attempting an armed power grab, there would be local citizens militias which would converge on the outbreak of violence and contain it.

Maybe it won’t work, maybe it will, but we won’t know until we try.

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by whatshisface on Sunday January 06, 2019 @11:41PM (#18842804)
>there would be local citizens militias which would converge on the outbreak of violence and contain it.

What if the first step in my evil plan was to gain the loyalty of the local militias by lauding their virtue and advocating that they should receive a bigger cut than everyone else because they're so brave and put themselves in the line of danger? Groups fall to ambitious leaders all the time, because people really eat up a charismatic leader with big promises. (See: how the Legions were talked installing a dictator in Rome.)

Re:Empathy and Failures of Democracies by fallingfrog on Sunday January 06, 2019 @11:56PM (#18842873)
I think there are 2 points I would use to respond to that. 1) it’s really, really hard to accumulate a large stockpile of money without exploiting the labor of other people and 2) no political system is immune to a 50% + 1 attack. By “citizens militia” I meant just ordinary people who own weapons so yeah if somebody comes along who is so charismatic that they can convince 50% + 1 people to follow them, it’s game over.