News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Toshiba Introduces MacBook Air 'Blade-Type' SSDs to Mass ... by jacquesm on Monday November 08, 2010 @03:52PM (#1883966)
Putting an SSD in to a 3.5 or 2.5" hard drive enclosure is indeed a waste of space, but talking 'mSATA' to what is essentially memory seems to be a waste of speed.

All that work to stuff data down a serial pipe emulating a harddisk that isn't even there.

Re:Toshiba Introduces MacBook Air 'Blade-Type' SSDs to Mass ... by AngryParsley on Monday November 08, 2010 @04:09PM (#1884016)
Flash has certain disadvantages that favor using a controller instead of direct addressing like DRAM. To make SSDs fast, you have to do wear leveling, command queueing, and parallelization of requests across all flash chips. Oh and when a cell fails, you have to remap spare cells. Doing this stuff in software would be a giant pain.

You can get raw flash chips, but it's hard to get decent performance and reliability out of them. That sort of setup is usually for embedded systems where writing is rare and read performance isn't important. Firmwares for switches and routers, for example.

Re:Toshiba Introduces MacBook Air 'Blade-Type' SSDs to Mass ... by Hoff on Monday November 08, 2010 @06:23PM (#1884490)
While I understand your comments and that this can get hairy, also consider a softmodem-like implementation as a counter-example.

A softmodem (variously also called a Winmodem) is a partial or full software implementation of a modem, and helped reduce the parts counts and the costs of modems.

Ugly or not, it's a near certainty that we'll see a software (or firmware) implementation of this; some sort of "softssd" or "winssd" scheme.

Re:Toshiba Introduces MacBook Air 'Blade-Type' SSDs to Mass ... by pmjordan on Monday November 08, 2010 @05:31PM (#1884319)
You'd need custom file systems, etc., plus no PC BIOS will boot from something that doesn't resemble an ATA device. The whole ecosystem is based on layers of legacies, you should know that by now!